Are you trying to argue that BK is a bad coach?
You're killing yourself if you're argument is he isn't a "coach-em-up" coach. ND outperforms our average recruiting class ranking by a decent margin. If anything, it's the failure to finish in that top 5-7 range on a yearly basis that is a legit gripe. What does that have to do with George Welsh?
BTW, I too spent a few years in Charlottesville. Absolutely beautiful place, and the Campus is gorgeous. I lived there when the Unite the Right invasion happened. Terrible shame.