using analytics to assist is good, being married to analytics rather than managing the game with a strategy that gives you the most possible slight advantages, is not.
The numbers you listed don't "lie" they are just tragically incomplete which could very well be painting a false picture, or a lie.
And from a strategic standpoint, putting the opposing coaches in more situations where they have to make decisions, opens the door for them to make mistakes...it's not like we haven't seen it happen before, actually I think it was either Weis or Kelly that blew that once and elected to kick off when the other team deferred.
If you want to have off board conversation on this and maybe partner up on collecting full stats let me know, but presenting this as the full picture is just false (and I admit, I don't know what full stats would show, might hold same trend, might not but worth looking into if you want to continue defending Kelly defying conventional wisdom).