"The lawfulness of an order, although an important issue, is not a discrete element of a disobedience offense. Therefore, it is a question of law to be determined by the military judge. MCM pt. IV, 14c(2)(a). United States v. Jeffers, 57 M.J. 13 (C.A.A.F. 2002); United States v. New, 55 M.J. 95 (C.A.A.F. 2001"
Link: Orders
Replies to: "Only a military judge can determine the lawfulness of an order."
- Baron in response to your post below regarding chain of command and such… - Domer From Hell - 10:23am 6/11/25
(24) [View All]
- Let's break this down.... [IMAGE]
- BaronVonZemo - 12:24pm 6/11/25
- Here’s my response… - Domer From Hell - 2:16pm 6/11/25
- I don’t care what side you’re on this is one of the better posts in this board in a very long time. - Frankx - 4:20pm 6/11/25
- You are so far out of your lane - Death - 12:37pm 6/11/25
- Here’s my response… - Domer From Hell - 2:16pm 6/11/25
- Which orders to the troops have been determined unlawful by the courts? [NT]
- NedoftheHill - 10:34am 6/11/25
- None as of now, however, I don’t think the courts have ruled yet. [NT]
- Domer From Hell - 10:41am 6/11/25
- The crap filed by Newsome is for the legality of the deployment. - PaND - 11:10am 6/11/25
- Dummy swerves out of his lane to obvious result. [NT] - ND521 - 12:18pm 6/11/25
- Wrong. The military is governed by civilian leadership for a reason… - Domer From Hell - 11:24am 6/11/25
- Only a military judge can determine the lawfulness of an order. [LINK]
- PaND - 1:49pm 6/11/25
- The legality of this deployment is going to be decided by a civilian court…. - Domer From Hell - 2:18pm 6/11/25
- It is pretty clear as a legal matter that the president has the authority to deploy. - NedoftheHill - 5:31pm 6/11/25
- The legality of this deployment is going to be decided by a civilian court…. - Domer From Hell - 2:18pm 6/11/25
- Given the abuse of local politically oriented judges,this could cripple our militaryincritical times - BaronVonZemo - 12:30pm 6/11/25
- Only a military judge can determine the lawfulness of an order. [LINK]
- PaND - 1:49pm 6/11/25
- Ah. Correct. I believe I misread your post. [NT] - NedoftheHill - 11:03am 6/11/25
- The crap filed by Newsome is for the legality of the deployment. - PaND - 11:10am 6/11/25
- None as of now, however, I don’t think the courts have ruled yet. [NT]
- Domer From Hell - 10:41am 6/11/25
- Let's break this down.... [IMAGE]
- BaronVonZemo - 12:24pm 6/11/25