UHND.com - Notre Dame Football, Basketball, & Recruiting

should have be closed is truly "Monday Morning Quarterbacking" and definitely debatable. Here's a Google AI Summary of the issue.

--------------------
AI Overview

In the early days of the COVID-19 pandemic, the decision to close schools was a complex one, involving significant debate and a lack of complete information about the virus and its effects.

Arguments in favor of initial school closures included:

Uncertainty about transmission: There was a lack of clear understanding about how easily the virus spread among children and the severity of illness in children.

Protecting vulnerable populations: School closures were seen as a way to reduce community transmission and protect at-risk adults and children.

Precautionary measure: School closures have historically been used in short bursts during pandemics, like influenza, to curb transmission.

Arguments against school closures and the observed consequences:

Incomplete evidence of effectiveness: Some studies suggest school closures alone were not a significant factor in curbing the virus, especially in comparison to other measures like masking and vaccination.

Educational and developmental disruption: Prolonged school closures led to significant learning loss, particularly for low-income and minority students, exacerbating existing educational inequalities.

Impact on mental health and well-being: Isolation and disruption to routine negatively impacted children's mental and physical health.
Current research and perspectives:

Initial closures may have been justifiable due to uncertainty: Given the initial unknowns, some temporary closures at the pandemic's outset may have been understandable.

Reopening schools safely should have been prioritized: As data emerged, revealing the effectiveness of mitigation strategies like masking, a quicker return to in-person learning with safety protocols should have been a greater priority.

The impact on students was significant and long-lasting: Studies continue to highlight the negative and potentially long-term academic, social, and emotional consequences for students, especially those from disadvantaged backgrounds.

Ultimately, whether the initial decision to close schools was "right" is complex and involves considering the unknown factors at the time against the eventual consequences that became clearer over time. The lessons learned highlight the importance of balancing public health concerns with the critical educational and developmental needs of children in future pandemic responses.
----------------------