Mattingly was a great hitter but he also was a great fielder. He had to be a star among some awful Yankee teams. I'd put Bonds and Clemens in too. Murphy was very good. Not sure on the others. I am pissed off that the voters didn't put Yogi Berra in on the first ballot who was considered one of the greatest catchers of all time, when you include his bat, clutch efforts and 10 world championships. They put Ozzie Smith in on the first ballot and though he was a wizard in the field. he couldn't hit.
This message has been edited 2 time(s).