List their accomplishments, teams, etc. And then note that significant evidence exists that they used performance-enhancing drugs late in their careers. I don't have the answer, but I do know that P.E.D. users are absolutely already in. I don't like Bagwell and Piazza and Ortiz having plaques but Bonds and Clemens not.
I'm not wild about Kent, simply because his best seasons coincided with Bonds behind him in the lineup giving him way better pitches to hit.
Agree with you on Mattingly.
Replies to: "Some have suggested simply putting it on their plaque."
- Basball H.O.F. - The 2026 Contemporary Era Ballot...let's discuss important things. - jakers - 10:50am 11/21/25
(21) [View All]
- Murphy played in a baseball desert - Fisher01 - 3:39pm 11/21/25
- With Mattingly, it's almost like the Terrell Davis situation. - jakers - 4:21pm 11/21/25
- Wait til they are dead, like they did with Ole Pete. [NT]
- LanceManion - 12:20pm 11/21/25
- This is actually the Leo Durocher rule - Mark - 1:34pm 11/21/25
- Paging Barry Bonds! A hole among a holes indeed. [NT]
- LanceManion - 3:08pm 11/21/25
- Barry Bonds is prone to getting a big head... [NT]
[IMAGE]
- TakethetrainKnute - 3:46pm 11/21/25
- And well earned...Pitchers knew the odds of Barry launching one into the stands were very good. - TyroneIrish - 6:05pm 11/21/25
- Barry Bonds is prone to getting a big head... [NT]
[IMAGE]
- TakethetrainKnute - 3:46pm 11/21/25
- Paging Barry Bonds! A hole among a holes indeed. [NT]
- LanceManion - 3:08pm 11/21/25
- But they are still holding fast with keeping Shoeless Joe out. [NT]
- ELP - 1:25pm 11/21/25
- His 1911 season is unfairly forgotten. - jakers - 3:28pm 11/21/25
- Maybe those heartless MFers should watch Field of Dreams. [NT] - LanceManion - 3:07pm 11/21/25
- Agree, and without the roids their numbers would not be so good. [NT] - PaND - 12:59pm 11/21/25
- This is actually the Leo Durocher rule - Mark - 1:34pm 11/21/25
- Bonds and Clemens deserve to have their plaques in the men's rest room above the urinals. [NT] - Hensou - 12:19pm 11/21/25
- I think there ought to be a steroid-era room - Chris94 - 12:09pm 11/21/25
- Agree on Bonds and Clemons...MLB was only too happy promoting the "Bash Brothers" before - TyroneIrish - 12:42pm 11/21/25
- Some have suggested simply putting it on their plaque. - jakers - 12:28pm 11/21/25
- I'd be fine with that - Chris94 - 12:32pm 11/21/25
- Enter under two giant crossed syringes... - TakethetrainKnute - 12:12pm 11/21/25
- Re: Basball H.O.F. - The 2026 Contemporary Era Ballot...let's discuss important things. - THEISMANCARR - 11:57am 11/21/25
- IMHO none of those men deserve to be in the HOF. [NT]
- Hensou - 11:42am 11/21/25
- I think Murphy is worth re-visiting. - jakers - 12:33pm 11/21/25
- Interesting thought. [NT] - THEISMANCARR - 12:40pm 11/21/25
- I think Murphy is worth re-visiting. - jakers - 12:33pm 11/21/25
- Murphy played in a baseball desert - Fisher01 - 3:39pm 11/21/25