Maybe the differences in opinion with the Renee Good incident is this

| Register

Upvote this post.

Downvote this post.

Maybe the differences in opinion with the Renee Good incident is this

Author: MarkHarman (7670 Posts - Original UHND Member)

Posted at 1:37 pm on Jan 13, 2026

View All

There is a line where, on one side, law enforcement is allowed to shoot at a moving car, and on the other side, they are not.

It seems to me (as a layman) that this incident is right on that line. There are forensics and legal experts who say it was a just shooting and others who say it wasn't.

I realize most people are going to default to their "team's" opinion on this, but when the people who are in the field can't agree, maybe this is truly an either/or situation.

Replies to: "Maybe the differences in opinion with the Renee Good incident is this"

Maybe the differences in opinion with the Renee Good incident is this - MarkHarman - 1:37pm 1/13/26 (21) [View All]
- Hard to believe an internal conduct review would find against the ICE agent. - LanceManion - 1:56pm 1/13/26
  - Former FBI Senior Agent alluded to that...Ross still violated CBP/ICE policy by standing (slightly) - TyroneIrish - 2:19pm 1/13/26
    - You can say this all day long but it's not true - MarkHarman - 3:43pm 1/13/26
      - It is true, Mark...please read the linked proof... [LINK] - TyroneIrish - 4:27pm 1/13/26
      - . [NT] - TyroneIrish - 4:19pm 1/13/26
- No that's not it - Chris94 - 1:40pm 1/13/26
  - You're missing one half of the equation... - iairishcheeks - 4:38pm 1/13/26
    - I don't doubt that she was being a pain in the ass. - Chris94 - 5:19pm 1/13/26
  - He was in front of the car, which she drove forward. After being told to get out of the car. [NT] - Hensou - 2:05pm 1/13/26
    - Officer Ross violated CBP/ICE Policy by creating a danger...and Ms. Good Turned her car to the Right - TyroneIrish - 2:16pm 1/13/26
      - You forgot to mention that she was ordered not to leave. Then she guns it. [NT] - ELP - 2:19pm 1/13/26
        According to CBP/ICE policy it doesn't matter whether she complied or not...no shooting at vehicles - TyroneIrish - 2:23pm 1/13/26
        You're not an expert. You've never been in the field. You never had to face this. Stop play acting. [NT] - ELP - 2:43pm 1/13/26
        Chill...I'm referencing the expert commentary of others...see what happens when you don't read other - TyroneIrish - 3:24pm 1/13/26
        There are many experts chiming in. I have to question the expert you chose. [NT] - ELP - 3:29pm 1/13/26
        As you should...and don't hesitate to share your thoughts with me...that's how forum discussions are - TyroneIrish - 3:57pm 1/13/26
        Not in the mood for another lecture. I'll pass. [NT] - ELP - 4:54pm 1/13/26
        Works for me...;-) [NT] - TyroneIrish - 5:07pm 1/13/26
- The CBP/ICE's Training Manual is explicit in its policy of not creating dangerous situations and - TyroneIrish - 1:40pm 1/13/26

Consent Management