Interesting discussion. At what point does a transitioning person become the other sex, if at all? And do they have the same rights as a person born into that sex? Basically an equal protection argument. ACLU argues heightened scrutiny s/b applied.
The ACLU seems to concede that just thinking you are the other gender doesn’t do the trick. So, wonder if this then swings the other way from their perspective to gain protection under ADA, but then you have to concede it is some form of disability.
Link: SC Case
ADVERTISEMENT
Alto questions ACLU lawyer on male/female in context of equal protection.
Replies to: "Alto questions ACLU lawyer on male/female in context of equal protection."
- Alto questions ACLU lawyer on male/female in context of equal protection. [LINK]
- LanceManion - 7:42am 1/14/26
(25) [View All]
- Great law school exam questions... issues galore! - Curly1918 - 11:56am 1/14/26
- At what point are they going to bring a biologist in to testify? [NT] - iairishcheeks - 11:50am 1/14/26
- I'm surprised the ACLU would concede this. [NT] - Frankx - 11:46am 1/14/26
- This lawyer is a total moron. Truly - a dolt. - jakers - 9:36am 1/14/26
- Yeah, it's an easy layup and especially for this court. The arguments show you how absurd this - LanceManion - 10:45am 1/14/26
- This is just nonsense the court is wasting their time on, they must be bored [NT]
- holybull101 - 8:47am 1/14/26
- Thank God Trump ran and won the first time and appointed the members he did. - LanceManion - 10:46am 1/14/26
- I can’t believe “what does it mean to be a woman or a man?” has made it to the - TampaIrish - 8:46am 1/14/26
- It's what Pope Leo was talking about (and yes, I know he was critical of the right as well). - LanceManion - 10:48am 1/14/26
- It's not "sex" that is the issue... it's mental illness. - Curly1918 - 8:37am 1/14/26
- It's a social contagion layered on top of various mental illnesses. - LanceManion - 10:49am 1/14/26
- Poor parenting is the root cause of [NT]
- holybull101 - 8:56am 1/14/26
- My wife works with one. - PaND - 9:04am 1/14/26
- Biden's World. [NT] - BaronVonZemo - 12:59pm 1/14/26
- Munchhausen syndrome by proxy [NT]
- LanceManion - 10:54am 1/14/26
- Yep. [NT] - iairishcheeks - 11:00am 1/14/26
- Child abuse aided by the state. Sad. [NT] - NedoftheHill - 10:33am 1/14/26
- My wife works with one. - PaND - 9:04am 1/14/26
- He’s not off-bass with the tenor of those queries… [NT]
- TakethetrainKnute - 8:26am 1/14/26
- Well done [NT] - Chris94 - 1:45pm 1/14/26
- If he gets into treble, he risks turning this into an episode of sopranos. [NT] - NedoftheHill - 10:30am 1/14/26
- Is there a chance SCOTUS will throw this back to the individual states? [NT]
- ELP - 9:04am 1/14/26
- No. If they wanted to punt don't think they would have taken the case. [NT] - LanceManion - 10:44am 1/14/26
- Not if Title IX is central to the ruling. [NT] - Curly1918 - 9:19am 1/14/26
Consent Management