Of course not. It would be silly for anyone to suggest it does.

Author: NedoftheHill (46953 Posts - Joined: Jun 30, 2011)

Posted at 2:05 am on Jul 1, 2026

View All

Regarding my question: You seem unconcerned. I suspect you underestimate the PRC.

Can I also ask: Why is it so important that babies born in the United States automatically become US citizens, regardless of all other factors? Why is that so important to you?

This message has been edited 2 time(s).

Evil preaches tolerance until it is dominant, then it tries to silence good.

Replies to: “Of course not. It would be silly for anyone to suggest it does.”

Hard to believe Trump v Barbara wasn't 9-0 re birthright citizenship. [NT] [LINK] - conorlarkin - 4:28pm 6/30/26 (24) [View All]
- Conor: honest question re Alito's security concerns - NedoftheHill - 8:14pm 6/30/26
  - Immigration policy does not trump the US Constitution. - conorlarkin - 11:46pm 6/30/26
    - Of course not. It would be silly for anyone to suggest it does. - NedoftheHill - 2:05am 7/1/26
- Agreed...and wrongly. Guess we will need an Article V Amendment to get it right. - NedoftheHill - 4:45pm 6/30/26
  - It was not a close legal issue, Ned. [LINK] - conorlarkin - 6:02pm 6/30/26
    - It was not a 9-0 ruling, as you admit. Now you are just posturing. - NedoftheHill - 6:34pm 6/30/26
  - Just think of it like The Hunger Games. - iairishcheeks - 5:01pm 6/30/26
  - There was no intent to ban citizenship for "illegals." There was no such thing then. [NT] - Chris94 - 4:52pm 6/30/26
    - There was no intent to extend citizenship to them. They didn't exist then, as you say. [NT] - NedoftheHill - 4:55pm 6/30/26
      - Atta Boy, Ned...make those kids "Stateless" with no rights whatsoever...I believe our Founders had [LINK] - TyroneIrish - 6:27pm 6/30/26
        
        When are you going to stop with the strawman arguments? - NedoftheHill - 7:41pm 6/30/26
        
        All you need to do is read the link I gave you…doesn’t look like you did. Not easy to have an - TyroneIrish - 1:57am 7/1/26
        
        Attaboy, Tyrone, destroy the US by making welfare state & offering it to 8B people. [NT] - NedoftheHill - 6:31pm 6/30/26
        
        When are you going to stop with the "Straw Man" arguments? ;-)...8B?....Seriously?...Read the link I - TyroneIrish - 7:34pm 6/30/26
        
        We'll need fleets of street sweepers just to clean up the placentae alone... [NT] - TakethetrainKnute - 7:09pm 6/30/26
        
        Thank you Ned for acknowledging your agreement with the dissent was not law based. - conorlarkin - 7:08pm 6/30/26
        
        Thank you for admitting you oppose traditional constitutional scholarship. - NedoftheHill - 7:37pm 6/30/26
      - People born in America were Americans. That's the intent. That's the wording. - Chris94 - 5:16pm 6/30/26
        
        We agree on this one. [NT] - iairishcheeks - 5:47pm 6/30/26
        
        Nuance, 94, nuance. I can’t believe you can’t see it. [NT] - jimbasil - 5:22pm 6/30/26
        
        Indeed. Not a 9-0 decision. But you see only one side. [NT] - NedoftheHill - 6:35pm 6/30/26
        
        yeah, the side that says born on US soil makes you an American. You see the side - jimbasil - 9:43pm 6/30/26
  - Well, we all agree nuance is your greatest feature, to do a “ Not” joke. Nuance. [NT] - jimbasil - 4:49pm 6/30/26
- It is depressing that 4 justices could ignore the clear wording of the Constitution. - Chris94 - 4:33pm 6/30/26

Consent Management