I don't see how you seriously say that. I love McHale and there is no doubt he was a very good player. But KG can do things McHale couldn't even think about doing (one of which was passing). McHale may have been a slightly better scorer then Garnett, maybe. After that, KG gets the nod in almost every other area.
Put McHale in a situation where he doesn't have one of the top 5 players of all time along side of him and we would have probably forgot about him by now.
Replies to: "Really?"
- An ESPN talking head was at it again re: the Pierce/Bird comparison yesterday - McSweeney - 10:21am 6/10/08
(39) [View All]
- One player from these two teams would start on the 80s squads - FratBoy - 12:30pm 6/10/08
- Anybody who would take Garnett over McHale if you needed points - JohnDoe - 4:11pm 6/10/08
- Really? - NDNEIL - 4:35pm 6/10/08
- I agree with Neil and Bettis. Both Kobe and KG would easily be starters. - McSweeney - 2:23pm 6/10/08
- I would start KG over McHale - NDNEIL - 12:41pm 6/10/08
- I think KG could start over both McHale and AC Green... - Bettis6 - 12:39pm 6/10/08
- I think Gasol would get on the court. - saNDiego03 - 3:15pm 6/10/08
- You, sir, are insane - FratBoy - 5:35pm 6/10/08
- I think Gasol is the 4th best player after Magic, Kareem, and Kobe. - saNDiego03 - 12:50am 6/11/08
- You, sir, are insane - FratBoy - 5:35pm 6/10/08
- As a PF, Id take McHale - FratBoy - 2:21pm 6/10/08
- I think Gasol would get on the court. - saNDiego03 - 3:15pm 6/10/08
- Anybody who would take Garnett over McHale if you needed points - JohnDoe - 4:11pm 6/10/08
- But it was Bob Ryan that made the initial comparison - Chris94 - 11:32am 6/10/08
- My guy, Bill Walton, pooh-poohed it yesterday.... [IMAGE]
- Bettis6 - 11:22am 6/10/08
- Bill Walton is right up there with Brent Pussburger in terms of shitheadedness - LanceManion - 12:33pm 6/10/08
- What if I tell you that Stephen A. Smith is my second favorite analyst? - Bettis6 - 12:41pm 6/10/08
- I'll light a candle for you in church. Dear Lord. [NT]
- LanceManion - 12:46pm 6/10/08
- I'm not a big fan of tweeners... - Bettis6 - 12:57pm 6/10/08
- So I gather - [NT] - LanceManion - 12:58pm 6/10/08
- I'm not a big fan of tweeners... - Bettis6 - 12:57pm 6/10/08
- I'll light a candle for you in church. Dear Lord. [NT]
- LanceManion - 12:46pm 6/10/08
- What if I tell you that Stephen A. Smith is my second favorite analyst? - Bettis6 - 12:41pm 6/10/08
- Re: My guy, Bill Walton, pooh-poohed it yesterday.... - STLRamFan1 - 12:17pm 6/10/08
- Do you think Boston has anything to do with it? - Bettis6 - 12:25pm 6/10/08
- Re: Do you think Boston has anything to do with it? - STLRamFan1 - 2:25pm 6/10/08
- There are 10 teams that outdraw LA in terms of straight-up arena attendance - McSweeney - 3:49pm 6/10/08
- Re: There are 10 teams that outdraw LA in terms of straight-up arena attendance - STLRamFan1 - 6:20pm 6/10/08
- There are 10 teams that outdraw LA in terms of straight-up arena attendance - McSweeney - 3:49pm 6/10/08
- Re: Do you think Boston has anything to do with it? - STLRamFan1 - 2:25pm 6/10/08
- Do you think Boston has anything to do with it? - Bettis6 - 12:25pm 6/10/08
- Your guy? That saddens me, Bettis. - McSweeney - 11:28am 6/10/08
- Does anyone else see the resemblance? - IrishinMass - 3:10pm 6/10/08
- Hey now, my Knicks hatred is tenuous as it is - McSweeney - 3:36pm 6/10/08
- Fair enough. - IrishinMass - 3:49pm 6/10/08
- Hey now, my Knicks hatred is tenuous as it is - McSweeney - 3:36pm 6/10/08
- Reggie Miller is my favorite player ever. - jakers - 2:26pm 6/10/08
- I really admired Reggie too. - saNDiego03 - 3:13pm 6/10/08
- You're preaching to the choir - McSweeney - 2:45pm 6/10/08
- Sadly, it didn't even have to come to that. - jakers - 2:59pm 6/10/08
- Ahh yes, the Mark Jackson ass-back maneuver - McSweeney - 3:34pm 6/10/08
- Sadly, it didn't even have to come to that. - jakers - 2:59pm 6/10/08
- Throw it DOWN Big Fella! [NT] - lady_irish - 12:09pm 6/10/08
- Yeah, I know. I used to hate him.... - Bettis6 - 11:37am 6/10/08
- I probably hated the Knicks in the mid to late 90s more than I hate the Patriots now - McSweeney - 11:52am 6/10/08
- I remember that moment very well... - Bettis6 - 12:01pm 6/10/08
- I probably hated the Knicks in the mid to late 90s more than I hate the Patriots now - McSweeney - 11:52am 6/10/08
- Does anyone else see the resemblance? - IrishinMass - 3:10pm 6/10/08
- Bill Walton is right up there with Brent Pussburger in terms of shitheadedness - LanceManion - 12:33pm 6/10/08
- For all the people that have tried to start a new football league - Slacker - 10:40am 6/10/08
- Bird was not a complete player? - NDNEIL - 10:38am 6/10/08
- Re: Bird was not a complete player? - STLRamFan1 - 12:14pm 6/10/08
- They're trying to sell the finals - Hank Scorpio - 10:33am 6/10/08
- One player from these two teams would start on the 80s squads - FratBoy - 12:30pm 6/10/08