Menu
UHND.com - Notre Dame Football, Basketball, & Recruiting
Football
2023 Notre Dame Football Schedule
2023 Notre Dame Roster
2022 Notre Dame Coaching Staff
Injury News & Updates
Notre Dame Football Depth Charts
Notre Dame Point Spreads & Betting Odds
Notre Dame Transfers
NFL Fighting Irish
Game Archive
Player Archive
Past Seasons & Results
Recruiting
Commits
News & Rumors
Class of 2018 Commit List
Class of 2019 Commit List
Class of 2020 Commit List
Class of 2021 Commit List
Archives
History
Notre Dame Bowl History
Notre Dame NFL Draft History
Notre Dame Football ESPN GameDay History
Notre Dame Heisman Trophy Winners
Notre Dame Football National Championships
Notre Dame Football Rivalries
Notre Dame Stadium
Touchdown Jesus
Basketball
Forums
Chat Room
Football Forum
Open Forum
Basketball Board
Ticket Exchange
Videos
Notre Dame Basketball Highlights
Notre Dame Football Highlights
Notre Dame Football Recruiting Highlights
Notre Dame Player Highlights
Hype Videos
Latest News
Gear
About
Advertise With Us
Contact Us
Our RSS Feeds
Community Rules
Privacy Policy
RSS
YouTube
Twitter
Facebook
Home
>
Forums
>
The Open Forum
Login
|
Register
Username
Password
Remember me
Sign in
By "when he earned that money" I was referring to the income tax.
Author:
NedoftheHill
(41297 Posts - Joined: Jun 29, 2011)
Posted at 12:04 am on Oct 20, 2017
View All
(no message)
This message has been edited 1 time(s).
Evil preaches tolerance until it is dominant, then it tries to silence good.
Replies to: "By "when he earned that money" I was referring to the income tax."
Why does the GOP want to eliminate the estate tax before eliminating all federal income taxes?
-
NDinKentucky
- 9:21am 10/19/17
(43)
[View All]
The Federal income tax should never have been initiated but probably too late now to blow it up
-
CC72
- 11:39am 10/19/17
Speaking of taxes, is this okay with you?
[NT]
[
IMAGE
]
-
golfkrzy
- 10:59am 10/19/17
I'm not sure what this has to do with my original post.
-
NDinKentucky
- 11:09am 10/19/17
Because it’s post tax money the govt steals from families and because it’ easier to make the case
-
BaronVonZemo
- 9:29am 10/19/17
So if I work for my money, and my neighbor inherits all of his money, I should be paying for roads
-
NDinKentucky
- 9:47am 10/19/17
The roads were already paid for by him when his parents earned that money.
-
NedoftheHill
- 12:03pm 10/19/17
I think the estate tax applies regardless of whether the heirs are family or not.
-
LehighND
- 1:27pm 10/19/17
It taxes twice. That is the starter. Most inheritances are to family members. Also a starter
-
NedoftheHill
- 1:48pm 10/19/17
This is objectively false.
-
LanceHarbor
- 7:32pm 10/19/17
You are saying that no one ever uses their income to buy capital gain assets? What do they use?
[NT]
-
NedoftheHill
- 12:04am 10/20/17
Sigh.
-
LehighND
- 1:45pm 10/20/17
No, it wasn't. "The roads were already paid for by him when his parents earned that money".
-
LehighND
- 4:29pm 10/19/17
By "when he earned that money" I was referring to the income tax.
[NT]
-
NedoftheHill
- 12:04am 10/20/17
Right. My dad paid taxes too.
-
LehighND
- 1:41pm 10/20/17
and, what if the estate is in fixed assets...such as a farm...why should the kids have to sell the
-
WestCoastIrishFan
- 11:38am 10/19/17
Your argument is predicated around the fact that farmland has more sentimental value than a
-
NDinKentucky
- 11:47am 10/19/17
Stocks and bonds are more like currency than they are like a farm.
-
NedoftheHill
- 1:53pm 10/19/17
You can count the number of farms sold due to estate tax over the past 30 years on 1 hand.
[NT]
-
LanceHarbor
- 7:35pm 10/19/17
I suspect this is objectively false.
[NT]
-
NedoftheHill
- 12:05am 10/20/17
Land is much easier to sell than you think, it's a finite commodity,
-
NDinKentucky
- 2:30pm 10/19/17
The exemption has been as low as $600k in recent history (with rates as high as 55%)
-
NedoftheHill
- 3:52pm 10/19/17
The first exemption passes to the second spouse.
-
LanceHarbor
- 7:40pm 10/19/17
The exemption is 5.45 million today, so who cares when it was last at 600k that's irrelevant. The
-
NDinKentucky
- 4:03pm 10/19/17
So eliminate the estate tax on farms and quit giving so many subsidies?
[NT]
-
NDinKentucky
- 2:26pm 10/19/17
Ok.
[NT]
-
NedoftheHill
- 3:34pm 10/19/17
It has nothing to do with sentimental value. Why should a farming family be
-
WestCoastIrishFan
- 11:58am 10/19/17
99.5% don't because they don't have more than $11,000,000 worth of land.
-
LehighND
- 4:34pm 10/19/17
It's actually 99.8%.
[NT]
-
LanceHarbor
- 7:41pm 10/19/17
Why do you beleive the government has any right to my income? That I work for.
[NT]
-
NDinKentucky
- 4:19pm 10/19/17
Sell the acerage, and rent the land like everyone else who farms and doesn't inherit 5,000 acres of
-
NDinKentucky
- 1:39pm 10/19/17
And who buys the farms...big business. Exactly who you don't want to have them.
[NT]
-
WestCoastIrishFan
- 1:57pm 10/19/17
Private Equity firms buying the farms wouldn't be a bad thing for the farmer if his farming
-
NDinKentucky
- 4:08pm 10/19/17
Why bother waiting? We could just let the state own the farms now.
-
NedoftheHill
- 1:55pm 10/19/17
do you suppose the "family" paid more than others while accumulating their wealth? Do you suppose
-
WestCoastIrishFan
- 11:36am 10/19/17
Directly, no, because he is not paying tax on wealth accumulation before spending like everyone else
-
NDinKentucky
- 11:45am 10/19/17
but i bet you believe unemployment and welfare should have no end date?
[NT]
-
WestCoastIrishFan
- 11:47am 10/19/17
One would assume less people would be on welfare if minimum wage workers weren't paying more
-
NDinKentucky
- 11:55am 10/19/17
so, you're going to legislate your morality? Awesome.
[NT]
-
WestCoastIrishFan
- 12:08pm 10/19/17
No.... I'm going to legislate on my conservative viewpoint that estate taxes are less inefficient on
-
NDinKentucky
- 2:07pm 10/19/17
I never understand why the estate tax bothers anyone.
-
LehighND
- 10:14am 10/19/17
And to back you up on this, it's not the first 5 mil that's tax free
-
NDinKentucky
- 10:29am 10/19/17
We should go with 100% estate tax and 0% income tax.
-
Iggle
- 10:28am 10/19/17
We'd have to rewrite a lot of detail on estate tax codes, since the amount of loopholes
-
NDinKentucky
- 10:32am 10/19/17