I doubt anyone would quibble with the promises Baron listed, for example.
My totally non-statistical perception of presidential promise-keeping over the past 40 years:
Fairly good: Obama, Trump
Not so good: Reagan, Both Bushes, Clinton
All have some major promise that wasn't kept. I think about the red meat Reagan threw to Christian conservatives, but in retrospect, didn't deliver on much. Signed onto budgets that ballooned the deficit. Libertarians back then despised him. And yes, I would say, ironically, Trump has delivered more to Christian conservatives than Reagan ever did.
Again, maybe I'm wrong with those perceptions, but it doesn't surprise me that Obama and Trump especially riled the opposite side, since they tended to follow through on things for which their rivals strenuously objected.