It's easier to have this conversation about football players, since the stats are not as cut-and-dry. Some players on here are not highly rated at all (Rizzuto?). And I'm not sure Reggie or Nolan Ryan should be on the list - is anyone is unaware of their weaknesses? But I like the bits about Jeter, natch.
If you want to talk overrated, I think Ozzie Smith has to be in the conversation. Unless you think 28 HRs in 19 years is good...but at least he hit over .300 once. Once.
Shots fired!
Link: https://sportscroll.com/major-league-baseballs-25-most-overrated-players/20/