Do we crack it open for the guys for which there is overwhelming evidence, but no proof (Clemens, Bonds)? Fine, then how about the guys that got busted multiple times (Manny, A-Rod)?
This is the gift that Bud Selig / Donald Fehr left us. Bud is in the HOF, btw. Ain't that a kick in the ass?
My inclination is to err on the side of the players who we reasonably suspect are clean. If you are stained by steroids, too bad. You'll have to take solace in your millions of dollars, but you're not getting in. This isn't life or death, it's a freakin club. There are far greater tragedies in life.