You just have to pick your poison.
Usually at this time of year there are a fair number of posters lobbying for the second stringer or for the freshman who just arrived on campus. Usually, I back the starter, thinking that the coaches probably see more than I see. But, my worries about Wimbush aren't that he sucks. I just worry that his style does not match Kelly's offense, and Kelly is not flexible enough to build an offense to exploit Wimbush's style.
Back to the point: I'm for the best player to play, taking into account the weaknesses of the coach.