Menu
UHND.com - Notre Dame Football, Basketball, & Recruiting
Football
2023 Notre Dame Football Schedule
2023 Notre Dame Roster
2022 Notre Dame Coaching Staff
Injury News & Updates
Notre Dame Football Depth Charts
Notre Dame Point Spreads & Betting Odds
Notre Dame Transfers
NFL Fighting Irish
Game Archive
Player Archive
Past Seasons & Results
Recruiting
Commits
News & Rumors
Class of 2018 Commit List
Class of 2019 Commit List
Class of 2020 Commit List
Class of 2021 Commit List
Archives
History
Notre Dame Bowl History
Notre Dame NFL Draft History
Notre Dame Football ESPN GameDay History
Notre Dame Heisman Trophy Winners
Notre Dame Football National Championships
Notre Dame Football Rivalries
Notre Dame Stadium
Touchdown Jesus
Basketball
Forums
Chat Room
Football Forum
Open Forum
Basketball Board
Ticket Exchange
Videos
Notre Dame Basketball Highlights
Notre Dame Football Highlights
Notre Dame Football Recruiting Highlights
Notre Dame Player Highlights
Hype Videos
Latest News
Gear
About
Advertise With Us
Contact Us
Our RSS Feeds
Community Rules
Privacy Policy
RSS
YouTube
Twitter
Facebook
Home
>
Forums
>
Football Message Board
Login
|
Register
Username
Password
Remember me
Sign in
Yeah, I don't write him off. I agree with your logic of - on what basis, given we know what we have.
Author:
oldirish
(8703 Posts - Joined: Oct 8, 2011)
Posted at 5:08 pm on Mar 8, 2019
View All
(no message)
Replies to: "Yeah, I don't write him off. I agree with your logic of - on what basis, given we know what we have."
Here's why Phil Jurkovec should start Spring practice as the #1 QB.
-
Irishize
- 7:39am 2/28/19
(63)
[View All]
Napoleon is right. PJ is a NC QB like TL and Tua? Why did he not go from 3rd QB to 1st last year?
-
oldirish
- 9:52pm 2/28/19
Yeah. Kelly really knows how to develop QBs.
-
Aragoto
- 9:54am 3/1/19
About as smart as back to back to back sticking with paper talented QBs when they proved they
-
oldirish
- 9:10pm 3/7/19
First of all it has been one year and in the action he got, he looked talented but with
-
THEISMANCARR
- 4:53pm 3/1/19
In Kelly’s seniority system Book starts this year as well. Moot point however.
-
Aragoto
- 5:35pm 3/1/19
I’m not saying Jurkovec can’t be the guy.
-
Napoleon
- 8:01am 3/1/19
Yeah, I don't write him off. I agree with your logic of - on what basis, given we know what we have.
[NT]
-
oldirish
- 5:08pm 3/8/19
Re: I’m not saying Jurkovec can’t be the guy.
-
Irishize
- 8:23am 3/1/19
Why would you rock the boat until there is actual proof? This has been Kelly's biggest downfall at
-
oldirish
- 5:11pm 3/8/19
This is pretty much where I am at
-
D2
- 11:37am 3/1/19
Agreed. I think Book is better maybe than you give credit, but he is horrible at the deep ball.
[NT]
-
oldirish
- 5:14pm 3/8/19
Okay.
-
Napoleon
- 9:13am 3/1/19
Re: Napoleon is right. PJ is a NC QB like TL and Tua? Why did he not go from 3rd QB to 1st last year?
-
Irishize
- 7:15am 3/1/19
Seriously? Kelly would sit a QB whom he KNEW was better because of seniority?
-
irishone
- 4:07pm 3/1/19
Disagree
-
croaker
- 8:31pm 2/28/19
I thought I had heard this story before..."Ian Book's college success led to projections that he
-
BrashithAleim
- 5:18pm 2/28/19
Wow! Give me a break. A lot of championship QBs have lost in the Super Bowl. Even Tom
-
THEISMANCARR
- 3:02pm 2/28/19
The most popular player on any team is always the back-up qb
-
D2
- 12:54pm 2/28/19
That low ceiling could start for vast majority of team in country
[NT]
-
ColeyO
- 2:18pm 2/28/19
There is no team in the top 15 at the end of the year( besides ND) that Book would start for
-
D2
- 3:22pm 2/28/19
Wow
-
WoodstockIrish
- 4:28pm 2/28/19
I don't think ND "certainly would have lost to Michigan" if the game was later in the year.
-
Napoleon
- 4:03pm 2/28/19
Nor do I.
[NT]
-
TakethetrainKnute
- 8:02am 3/1/19
You are full of shit. Get a grip. Guys
-
ColeyO
- 3:36pm 2/28/19
Thanks for Your Input Mrs. Book!
[NT]
-
Corbulo
- 8:29pm 2/28/19
I always thought it was the Kicker. That is until he misses the winning FG.
[NT]
-
whatsamataU
- 3:18pm 2/28/19
Thanks for your input Mr. and Mrs. Jurkovec. It was much appreciated.
[NT]
-
fedman
- 12:35pm 2/28/19
Everthing you say about PJ is pure.
-
ColeyO
- 10:55am 2/28/19
Agree, as long competition is indeed, "open"
[NT]
-
Rooster
- 11:58am 2/28/19
Based on what?
-
565 Zahm Hall
- 10:55am 2/28/19
Agree. Clemson did not waste a year babying Trevor Lawrence.
-
Aragoto
- 10:18am 2/28/19
Re: Agree. Clemson did not waste a year babying Trevor Lawrence.
-
Irishize
- 11:35am 2/28/19
Lawrence was an early enrollee.
-
Napoleon
- 12:11pm 2/28/19
Having an NFL-ready quarterback run the scout team would certainly demonstrate something...
-
TakethetrainKnute
- 11:52am 2/28/19
Only if Kelly gets hit by a bus. Book will start, after 9 years why would you think otherwise
[NT]
-
PBHangingChad
- 10:14am 2/28/19
Kelly switched QBs last year while undefeated.
-
Napoleon
- 12:24pm 2/28/19
Re: Kelly switched QBs last year while undefeated.
-
Irishize
- 12:34pm 2/28/19
This is true. I often wonder if someone forced Kelly, because he was adamant on BW.
[NT]
-
oldirish
- 5:16pm 3/8/19
Think about it.
-
Napoleon
- 2:13pm 2/28/19
Yeah, but it took Kelly a solid 15 months to figure this out when it was clear well before he
-
oldirish
- 5:17pm 3/8/19
Re: Think about it.
-
Irishize
- 4:03pm 2/28/19
That assumes PJ will be the better QB in '19.
-
Napoleon
- 4:09pm 2/28/19
Re: That assumes PJ will be the better QB in '19.
-
Irishize
- 4:34pm 2/28/19
I think Book has more talent than you think. Also the offense gels well with him and has not with
-
oldirish
- 5:21pm 3/8/19
Hilarious.
-
Napoleon
- 5:15pm 2/28/19
Wally Pipp agrees.
[NT]
-
Aragoto
- 12:14pm 3/1/19
If it takes Bettis smacking him upside the head...so be it.
[NT]
-
TakethetrainKnute
- 10:29am 2/28/19
Let’s see if he can win the Junior Jabie award at the BlueGold game first
[NT]
-
Shadow_of_the_Dome
- 9:56am 2/28/19
Without a superstar WR, I’ll take a 70% completion average QB , thank you very much.
[NT]
-
BaronVonZemo
- 9:51am 2/28/19
Catch 22. We can't have a superstar receiver if we don't have a QB who can go deep.
[NT]
-
Rooster
- 11:56am 2/28/19
Can he get the ball to the endzone on a 40 yrd hail mary?
[NT]
-
ND4EVR
- 9:35am 2/28/19
Ian Book has earned the starting spot. It's up to Jurkovec to wrest it from him.
-
ndunabomber
- 9:07am 2/28/19
Re: Ian Book has earned the starting spot. It's up to Jurkovec to wrest it from him.
-
Irishize
- 10:11am 2/28/19
You sabotaged your own point. Yes, in the VERY short time IB has been the ND
-
faircatchcorby
- 9:03am 2/28/19
.
[NT]
-
ColeyO
- 10:45am 2/28/19
This^^^^^^^^
[NT]
-
ColeyO
- 10:45am 2/28/19
Will there ever be a year when ND fans don't want the backup QB to be the starter?
-
ND_in_DRO
- 8:39am 2/28/19
I doubt anyone wanted a different starter in 2005 and 2006
[NT]
-
ndunabomber
- 10:11am 2/28/19
I doubt it.
-
Napoleon
- 9:10am 2/28/19
nauseating
[NT]
-
WestCoastIrishFan
- 8:31am 2/28/19
let it play out, Ian had a really nice year led us to the playoffs
[NT]
-
DonMiller
- 8:08am 2/28/19
As the recent issue of B&G pointed out, Book showed flashes, but did it against
-
cubsfanin16
- 11:31am 2/28/19
Re: let it play out, Ian had a really nice year led us to the playoffs
-
Irishize
- 8:44am 2/28/19