I'm not arguing that Montana didn't have a good amount of athleticism. I acknowledged that he was a pretty good bball player. He didn't run much on the field but he had good mobility and could buy time while receivers worked to get open. His iconic pass to Dwight Clark in '81 playoff game was a perfect example. So, I know it seems like I'm putting him down, but I loved watching him play. He is one of my all time favorites as well.
Joe Theismann was simply a step above. His arm strength was way above average. He was fast and could scramble. He actually ran quite a bit while with the Irish. Some remember him with the Redskins only sitting in the pocket and throwing downfield, but that was their system.
BTW, being able to dunk when you're 6"2 is not overly spectacular. I could dunk when I was in college and I'm not quite as tall as he.
Love the discussion