Menu
UHND.com - Notre Dame Football, Basketball, & Recruiting
Football
2023 Notre Dame Football Schedule
2023 Notre Dame Roster
2022 Notre Dame Coaching Staff
Injury News & Updates
Notre Dame Football Depth Charts
Notre Dame Point Spreads & Betting Odds
Notre Dame Transfers
NFL Fighting Irish
Game Archive
Player Archive
Past Seasons & Results
Recruiting
Commits
News & Rumors
Class of 2018 Commit List
Class of 2019 Commit List
Class of 2020 Commit List
Class of 2021 Commit List
Archives
History
Notre Dame Bowl History
Notre Dame NFL Draft History
Notre Dame Football ESPN GameDay History
Notre Dame Heisman Trophy Winners
Notre Dame Football National Championships
Notre Dame Football Rivalries
Notre Dame Stadium
Touchdown Jesus
Basketball
Forums
Chat Room
Football Forum
Open Forum
Basketball Board
Ticket Exchange
Videos
Notre Dame Basketball Highlights
Notre Dame Football Highlights
Notre Dame Football Recruiting Highlights
Notre Dame Player Highlights
Hype Videos
Latest News
Gear
About
Advertise With Us
Contact Us
Our RSS Feeds
Community Rules
Privacy Policy
RSS
YouTube
Twitter
Facebook
Home
>
Forums
>
Football Message Board
Login
|
Register
Username
Password
Remember me
Sign in
Yes
Author:
CC72
(16793 Posts - Joined: Sep 5, 2010)
Posted at 8:18 pm on Sep 30, 2019
View All
(no message)
Replies to: "Yes"
To those knocking Ian Book
-
Clem
- 2:49pm 9/30/19
(41)
[View All]
Golson not being good in 2014 is revisionist history
-
NDNEIL
- 10:00pm 9/30/19
He was not just good,
-
Clem
- 5:43am 10/1/19
Looking at year 1 vs two it appears Kelly introduces a level of complexity for QBs that is total
-
oldirish
- 8:20pm 9/30/19
He
-
WoodstockIrish
- 5:03pm 9/30/19
Totally agree on Ian,
-
Clem
- 5:19pm 9/30/19
Golson wasn't elite
-
NDNEIL
- 9:55pm 9/30/19
Disagree, Golson absolutely had elite ability.
-
Clem
- 5:47am 10/1/19
Being elite requires you display ability on Saturday's not on paper.
[NT]
-
oldirish
- 8:31pm 10/1/19
Didn't say he was an elite QB.
-
Clem
- 8:39am 10/2/19
You can't have elite ability if it's never displayed. This is true for many reasons but the most
-
oldirish
- 10:11pm 10/2/19
Not gonna argue semantics with ya,
-
Clem
- 4:06pm 10/3/19
How come none of these QBs benefited from personal coaches or succeeded in the NFL?
[NT]
-
CC72
- 6:57pm 9/30/19
Those two things are the key indicators they were more overrated than good.
[NT]
-
oldirish
- 8:05pm 9/30/19
Yes
[NT]
-
CC72
- 8:18pm 9/30/19
Being observant of Book's inability to throw deep and piss poor reads aren't knocks, they're facts.
[NT]
-
Jerseymick
- 3:19pm 9/30/19
Served your team well when he replaced
-
Clem
- 3:26pm 9/30/19
You guessed wrong hun, but nice try.
[NT]
-
Jerseymick
- 9:31am 10/1/19
^^^^^This^^^^^
[NT]
-
oldirish
- 8:06pm 9/30/19
Book starting to resemble Wimbush in several ways. He was a 3 star backup that’s not progressing to
-
whatsamataU
- 5:22pm 9/30/19
The case is certainly building that ND has a real development problem in the Kelly era re: QBs.
[NT]
-
Napoleon
- 9:16am 10/2/19
Wimbush was a four-star
-
Mark
- 5:49pm 9/30/19
Who's sitting on the bench at a MAC school.
[NT]
-
oldirish
- 8:08pm 9/30/19
Correction- he is sitting on the bench at an AAC school
-
CC72
- 8:22pm 9/30/19
I don't know if Gabriel was on ND's radar, but he was a well-regarded recruit. Offers from UGA and
-
Napoleon
- 9:08am 10/2/19
To be fair,
-
Clem
- 5:53am 10/1/19
Also to be fair: he was the starter, lost his job to injury and the kid who replaced him has done
-
Napoleon
- 11:52am 10/1/19
BW got the job because of injury. If the injury excuse makes you feel better, okay; I guess.
[NT]
-
oldirish
- 8:33pm 10/1/19
Not making an excuse. Pointing out a fact.
-
Napoleon
- 9:04am 10/2/19
It's fact he did not outright win the battle. He won by default due to injury. If he'd truly won he
-
oldirish
- 10:16pm 10/2/19
That is false.
-
Napoleon
- 10:35pm 10/2/19
Also, what does that tell us about the ND radar?
[NT]
-
oldirish
- 8:38pm 9/30/19
It's still the MAC. I know it's the AAC, but it's not big time. Granted they are pretty good.
[NT]
-
oldirish
- 8:37pm 9/30/19
Re: Served your team well when he replaced
[NT]
-
Clem
- 3:27pm 9/30/19
Agree. Let's knock whoever's responsible for his development.
[NT]
-
humbaba
- 3:19pm 9/30/19
Hard not to after numerous QB's
-
Clem
- 3:37pm 9/30/19
Or his recruitment, Southern Cal and half the Pac12 gets a guy that can throw every single year
[NT]
-
holybull101
- 3:35pm 9/30/19
It's hard to get it wrong that many times. It's definitely coaching.
[NT]
-
oldirish
- 8:10pm 9/30/19
none of them could start at other major programs. Just look at how
-
irishscooter
- 3:05pm 9/30/19
Except Golson couldn't start elsewhere so whose fault was it there? I think
-
Scottbrown5555
- 2:53pm 9/30/19
Golson started most of his season at FSU.
-
Napoleon
- 9:14am 10/2/19
You don't need a future NFL QB
-
Clem
- 3:15pm 9/30/19