You did forget about the part that they think the college football world is the same now as is was in the early 90s and there is simply no excuse for ND not to be scooping up 5 stars.
While I do not share your enthusiams for Kelly -- I am probably more in the half empty camp rather than half full camp while I grant he may have turned a corner -- lunacy and groupthink is pervasive at that other site. And that is because they hound, badger and bully anyone who isn't in the Kelly hater camp, all with the acquiescence and active enthusiam of the board mods there. Where else would a poster be allowed to effectively call an injured player a pussy, in direct violation of their alleged board rules, without any repercussion? And there were a few posters who were actually calling out that poster and were chastised for it because, of course, the poster in question "knew" the player wasn't really hurt, just 'mentally weak.'