Menu
UHND.com - Notre Dame Football, Basketball, & Recruiting
Football
2023 Notre Dame Football Schedule
2023 Notre Dame Roster
2022 Notre Dame Coaching Staff
Injury News & Updates
Notre Dame Football Depth Charts
Notre Dame Point Spreads & Betting Odds
Notre Dame Transfers
NFL Fighting Irish
Game Archive
Player Archive
Past Seasons & Results
Recruiting
Commits
News & Rumors
Class of 2018 Commit List
Class of 2019 Commit List
Class of 2020 Commit List
Class of 2021 Commit List
Archives
History
Notre Dame Bowl History
Notre Dame NFL Draft History
Notre Dame Football ESPN GameDay History
Notre Dame Heisman Trophy Winners
Notre Dame Football National Championships
Notre Dame Football Rivalries
Notre Dame Stadium
Touchdown Jesus
Basketball
Forums
Chat Room
Football Forum
Open Forum
Basketball Board
Ticket Exchange
Videos
Notre Dame Basketball Highlights
Notre Dame Football Highlights
Notre Dame Football Recruiting Highlights
Notre Dame Player Highlights
Hype Videos
Latest News
Gear
About
Advertise With Us
Contact Us
Our RSS Feeds
Community Rules
Privacy Policy
RSS
YouTube
Twitter
Facebook
Home
>
Forums
>
Football Message Board
Login
|
Register
Username
Password
Remember me
Sign in
Upvote this post.
0
Downvote this post.
πor π: Montana over Brady in a game for all the marbles. My vote: π What's yours?
Author:
Irishize
(7108 Posts - Joined: Dec 1, 2018)
Posted at 9:15 am on Jan 25, 2021
View All
(no message)
Replies to: "πor π: Montana over Brady in a game for all the marbles. My vote: π What's yours?"
πor π: Montana over Brady in a game for all the marbles. My vote: π What's yours?
[NT]
-
Irishize
- 9:15am 1/25/21
(51)
[View All]
Joe Cool, no brainer.
[NT]
-
irishfaninPA
- 12:49am 1/26/21
Brady has benefited greatly from the more protective rules for QBs & receivers. Montana 100%
-
Jerseymick
- 9:07pm 1/25/21
Those same rules applied to every one of Brady's contemporaries and yet...
-
Rooney
- 8:48am 1/26/21
Montana & Bradshaw together only add up to 8 Super Bowls. The Pats went 7-9 w/o
-
whatsamataU
- 9:01am 1/26/21
Belichick has a losing record in games not QB'd by Brady.
-
Rooney
- 9:24am 1/26/21
Probably same for The Gargantuan Grifter, Charlie Weis...
[NT]
-
TakethetrainKnute
- 9:32am 1/26/21
It's so true.
-
Rooney
- 9:45am 1/26/21
This refrain about Brady having "less supporting talent" than Montana is nonsense.
-
jakers
- 12:50pm 1/25/21
Is this how history will judge Mahomes?
-
iairishcheeks
- 5:09pm 1/25/21
Depends how many he wins, I guess.
[NT]
-
jakers
- 7:56pm 1/25/21
If you take away Lombardis for Spygate and Deflategate
-
Aragoto
- 3:39pm 1/25/21
Those are all GREAT points...you convinced me! (But I already agreed w/ you!)
[NT]
-
Law_Dogg
- 2:46pm 1/25/21
Your kill list ignores the AFC QBs that littered Brady path to the Super Bowl.
-
Rooney
- 2:44pm 1/25/21
Montana’s NFC title game conquests
-
Cheg80
- 9:13pm 1/25/21
Ick. What a motley crew.
-
Rooney
- 8:51am 1/26/21
The scores were ugly too
-
Cheg80
- 9:26pm 1/26/21
The 49'ers had superior talent on offense
-
ndunabomber
- 1:53pm 1/25/21
Amen brother
-
Nigel Tufnel
- 1:45pm 1/25/21
Montana all night long. Brady is great. Joe is greater, IMO.
[NT]
-
faircatchcorby
- 12:05pm 1/25/21
One game? Terry Bradshaw.
-
Aragoto
- 11:16am 1/25/21
According to Terry, he is availble to replace Ben
[NT]
-
pvm71
- 12:22pm 1/25/21
Bradshaw was asked if Brady and the Patriots were the best team of all time.
-
Aragoto
- 3:51pm 1/25/21
Sorry, have to go with Brady
-
ndunabomber
- 9:36am 1/25/21
You make a lot of good points, but Brady is 6-3 in Super Bowls to Joe's 4-0.
[NT]
-
Irishize
- 9:46am 1/25/21
It doesn’t matter. The history books will always point to Brady, especially with his longevity.
[NT]
-
whatsamataU
- 1:52pm 1/25/21
It is better to go to the Super Bowl than not go
-
humbaba
- 10:43am 1/25/21
Agreed - if my life was on the line, and I needed to win 1 game, it's Montana every day. Honestly...
-
Law_Dogg
- 9:50am 1/25/21
Brady's not the best under pressure?
-
Rooney
- 3:05pm 1/25/21
I mean actual pressure, not pressure of the situation
-
Law_Dogg
- 9:32am 1/27/21
I root against Brady every time because of the Michigan factor but he is the GOAT. Ironic part is at
-
THEISMANCARR
- 7:06pm 1/26/21
Since you acknowledged that you’re a Brady hater your opinion is meaningless
[NT]
-
PBHangingChad
- 2:59pm 1/25/21
That's a giant logical fallacy...
[NT]
-
Law_Dogg
- 3:43pm 1/27/21
Also, 2 of Brady's Super Bowl victories were gifts:
-
Irishize
- 10:08am 1/25/21
I don't know who I would pick but if you are going to talk about luck How about the missed intercep-
-
THEISMANCARR
- 8:54pm 1/25/21
Oooh, such a fun what if game you're playing.....
-
Rooney
- 10:51am 1/25/21
Yep nice work. Tell it like it is, even when it hurts.
[NT]
-
PBHangingChad
- 3:01pm 1/25/21
It pains me to agree, but I do.
[NT]
-
Frank L
- 2:09pm 1/25/21
2 of your scenarios are false.
-
jakers
- 1:35pm 1/25/21
My scenarios are as ridiculous as the ones I was responding to.
-
Rooney
- 2:35pm 1/25/21
You raised the points in a snarky post here, not me.
[NT]
-
jakers
- 3:03pm 1/25/21
I know. My point was we can play "what if" about any number of plays and get Brady 0-10 rings.
[NT]
-
Rooney
- 3:07pm 1/25/21
Your counterpoint to dismiss his post as stupid was to post falsehoods.
-
jakers
- 3:25pm 1/25/21
Took me a long time to give it up. Don't care for Brady...but he is the GOAT.
[NT]
-
TakethetrainKnute
- 10:55am 1/25/21
100% Agree.
[NT]
-
Domer From Hell
- 1:07pm 1/25/21
No way. He's the most accomplished, not the greatest...
-
Law_Dogg
- 12:29pm 1/25/21
OK...one vote for Dan Marino...
[NT]
-
TakethetrainKnute
- 12:51pm 1/25/21
If he is not the greatest, then who is?
-
humbaba
- 12:49pm 1/25/21
Montana was Brady's idol growing up in San Mateo, CA and
-
Irishize
- 11:21am 1/25/21
I was the same.
-
Rooney
- 11:15am 1/25/21
Same, when Brady got four, I still had Montana because of NC but no disputing
-
Hibakusha
- 11:37am 1/25/21
Lawrence Taylor would have made a big difference. Talk about a leading superstar, he as an OUTSIDE
-
THEISMANCARR
- 7:11pm 1/26/21