Considered a “can’t miss prospect” by many. Buchner was well regarded, but not at that level. Buchner also played at a relatively low level of competition in HS. Buchner transferred to a higher level, but lost the chance to play at that level due to COVID. Buchner also lost his sophomore season due to injury. So he really only had one season as a HS QB (and again, not at a high level). I think that sums it up. I think Buchner has a ton of talent, but didn’t expect him to do much as a freshman. He’s actually already exceeded my expectations. I’ll be shocked if he isn’t the guy next season and beyond. If he stays healthy, I think he has a chance to be great.
Link: https://www.si.com/college/recruiting/football/caleb-williams-talks-2020-elite-11-finals-mvp-award-oklahaoma-lsu-marylad