Arch Manning's tape does't scream legit 5*. Justin Fields tape was far better. Tyler Buchner's tape was more impressive showing more speed and as quick a release and he'd been a 5* if not for a weak performance at an off-season camp. If his tape was electric no one would say a thing. I think it's because his tape is just good and I don't think he's showing up at any of the camps the other top QBs have been at so folks have nothing but his tape to keep rewatching. If he went out and competed and stood next to some of these guys and threw ball-for-ball maybe we'd see just how much better he is or isn't.