Well for starters its one of the weakest QB classes over the last decade and for two Pyne was thought to be a 5* guy as a Soph but never really progressed alot from then and physically never grew much or put in much weight, so Rivals put him at 4* and others around 3.5 which is probably accurate. If you notice everyone in front of him is at least 6'3" and about 200lbbs. As a Soph he looked very good, albeit more 4* than 5* to me but pretty good as a Junior then as a Senior he regressed so he looked more like a guy right between 3*-4* but closer to 3*.