Correct, that he did win the MSU game, but he blew it against BC

You're entirely correct that he did throw that winning TD against MSU (almost purely by accident), but when he came in relief of a banged up Holliday against BC, to say he had a bad performance is a bit of an understatement.

I can still firmly remember that awful shovel pass he tried to throw, that got picked off and run back for a pick-6.