Notre Dame Fighting Irish Football & Recruiting // UHND.com

| Register

Upvote this post.

Downvote this post.

Unpopular opinion - ND should forego a transfer portal QB

Author: MarkHarman (5742 Posts - Original UHND Member)

Posted at 5:48 pm on Nov 24, 2022

View All

If ND does take a transfer QB, that would mean five scholarship QBs on the roster for 2023. Now, it's more than possible one or two might transfer out (my guess is Angeli would have a high probability of bailing), but it also sends a bad message to the entire QB room and potentially create a very toxic environment in that area.

Both Buchner and Pyne threw well in 2021, and it's hard to get an accurate assessment on Buchner's play this year with the O-line being so bad to start the season. My guess is that Freeman and Rees might just skip the transfer portal and go with Buchner in 2023. But I'm not solid on that guess.

Replies to: "Unpopular opinion - ND should forego a transfer portal QB"

Unpopular opinion - ND should forego a transfer portal QB - MarkHarman - 5:48pm 11/24/22 (41) [View All]
- If you can upgrade, do it! [NT] - bobdrake - 9:42am 11/25/22
- Personally, I get the "feel" that the team responds best with Pyne. Can't really prove it. [NT] - faircatchcorby - 9:25am 11/25/22
  - On the flip side, seems like Buchner has physical talent but not on-field leadership. Team seems to - jrdjr84 - 11:21am 11/25/22
    - It is normal to take charge more with the backup. Pyne makes enough plays to help us, just not - THEISMANCARR - 6:13pm 11/26/22
    - Anyone playing with that awfully-performing offensive line will have leadership issues - ndunabomber - 2:07pm 11/25/22
      - And be at risk to get injured [NT] - b2runn - 3:29pm 11/25/22
  - I'm sure they love it when he barely completes 50% of his passes. - AlbanyIRISH - 10:57am 11/25/22
    - 61% YTD, 19 TDs and only 5 INTs - WoodstockIrish - 11:06am 11/25/22
- It’s a decision not to be competitive…..just making that clear. [NT] - BaronVonZemo - 8:47am 11/25/22
- I posted here several times,,.I'm dead set against, - cubsfanin16 - 8:58pm 11/24/22
  - It all depends if they think Angeli is capable of stepping in if Buchner gets hurt next year. I - tky21 - 9:21pm 11/24/22
    - Re: It all depends if they think Angeli is capable of stepping in if Buchner gets hurt next year. I - b2runn - 9:50pm 11/24/22
      - Yes. And we really can't rely on Buchner either. So there better be someone else one way or another - tky21 - 10:34pm 11/24/22
- Whatever options that might actually exist in the transfer portal might not even be worth pursuing. - b2runn - 8:29pm 11/24/22
- Buchner is an injury risk, Pyne isn't a starter, that leaves Angeli and Minchey. - iairishcheeks - 7:22pm 11/24/22
  - I agree with this. Only thing we don't know is how good Angeli is. Buchner is an injury risk and - tky21 - 7:45pm 11/24/22
- “Buchner threw well” is the unpopular opinion [NT] - holybull101 - 6:57pm 11/24/22
  - Buchner threw well. No problem with his arm. Terrible protection, no running game, bad - tky21 - 7:16pm 11/24/22
    - You know what they say about excuses... [NT] - oldirish - 9:54pm 11/24/22
    - if he had great touch on the long ball, ND would have beaten Marshall and Styles would have had a TD - WestCoastIrishFan - 8:46pm 11/24/22
      - Geez a lot of long passes by pros and good college quarterbacks are missed long and short. Not as - THEISMANCARR - 11:11am 11/25/22
      - I said he "showed great touch on the deep ball." I didn't say he was automatic. The throw to Lenzy - tky21 - 9:07pm 11/24/22
        Admit it, you have a thing for him - WoodstockIrish - 6:35am 11/25/22
    - Is there another Buchner on the team? - WoodstockIrish - 7:58pm 11/24/22
      - Some things are debate-able, some things are not. The velocity he can put on throws is excellent. [NT] - tky21 - 9:09pm 11/24/22
        Your boy crush is getting embarrassing - WoodstockIrish - 6:37am 11/25/22
        
        Forget velocity, look at his play and his stats, this year and last year. Underwhelming at best. [NT] - NDQuebec - 12:22am 11/25/22
        He has the abilities is the point. He can see and has an arm that can make the throws. Any FBS QB - tky21 - 12:45pm 11/26/22
        
        Here are his stats this year [NT] [LINK] - NDQuebec - 12:22am 11/25/22
    - It sounds like we have the next John Elway, I’m sold, 12-0 [NT] - holybull101 - 7:36pm 11/24/22
      - If he can stay healthy, maybe 12-0. If Angeli is ready to be a good QB2 behind Buchner, I'm fine - tky21 - 7:40pm 11/24/22
- It comes down to this: Pyne is not a starter and simply cannot be the #2 next year. The staff is ex - tky21 - 6:53pm 11/24/22
  - You've now progressed well past die on this hill and are on to, die on this mountain range. [NT] - oldirish - 9:56pm 11/24/22
  - How is it you know so much about Buchner but somehow know nothing about Buchner - WoodstockIrish - 8:02pm 11/24/22
    - Nothing about my post indicates that I "know so much" about Buchner. [NT] - tky21 - 9:02pm 11/24/22
      - Seriously, you literally are fawning all over him and act like you are there with him at practice - WoodstockIrish - 6:40am 11/25/22
        We've not seen Angeli. We've seen Buchner last year and this year and he easily won the QB - tky21 - 5:00pm 11/25/22
        Ok, we agree about one thing.. We’ve seen Buchner, but we haven’t seen Angeli - WoodstockIrish - 5:04pm 11/25/22
  - That sounds like 3 losses [NT] - holybull101 - 6:59pm 11/24/22
    - I don't really know what this means. [NT] - tky21 - 7:18pm 11/24/22
- Re: Unpopular opinion - ND should forego a transfer portal QB - primo - 6:10pm 11/24/22