I realize with NIL, transfer portal,etc, college football now is on verge of a semi pro operation, but we're still ND.Id rather we go with an open competition and go with recruits who we brought to campus and maintain some semblance of a college football team.If that means sacrificing a few wins,eliminating us from the cFP, so be it.The portal is being the free agency system in pro sports.No thank you, I'll go with 4 kids we have.
I posted here several times,,.I'm dead set against,
Replies to: "I posted here several times,,.I'm dead set against,"
- Unpopular opinion - ND should forego a transfer portal QB - MarkHarman - 5:48pm 11/24/22
(41) [View All]
- If you can upgrade, do it! [NT] - bobdrake - 9:42am 11/25/22
- Personally, I get the "feel" that the team responds best with Pyne. Can't really prove it. [NT]
- faircatchcorby - 9:25am 11/25/22
- On the flip side, seems like Buchner has physical talent but not on-field leadership. Team seems to - jrdjr84 - 11:21am 11/25/22
- It is normal to take charge more with the backup. Pyne makes enough plays to help us, just not - THEISMANCARR - 6:13pm 11/26/22
- Anyone playing with that awfully-performing offensive line will have leadership issues - ndunabomber - 2:07pm 11/25/22
- And be at risk to get injured [NT] - b2runn - 3:29pm 11/25/22
- I'm sure they love it when he barely completes 50% of his passes. - AlbanyIRISH - 10:57am 11/25/22
- 61% YTD, 19 TDs and only 5 INTs - WoodstockIrish - 11:06am 11/25/22
- On the flip side, seems like Buchner has physical talent but not on-field leadership. Team seems to - jrdjr84 - 11:21am 11/25/22
- It’s a decision not to be competitive…..just making that clear. [NT] - BaronVonZemo - 8:47am 11/25/22
- I posted here several times,,.I'm dead set against, - cubsfanin16 - 8:58pm 11/24/22
- It all depends if they think Angeli is capable of stepping in if Buchner gets hurt next year. I - tky21 - 9:21pm 11/24/22
- Re: It all depends if they think Angeli is capable of stepping in if Buchner gets hurt next year. I - b2runn - 9:50pm 11/24/22
- Yes. And we really can't rely on Buchner either. So there better be someone else one way or another - tky21 - 10:34pm 11/24/22
- Re: It all depends if they think Angeli is capable of stepping in if Buchner gets hurt next year. I - b2runn - 9:50pm 11/24/22
- It all depends if they think Angeli is capable of stepping in if Buchner gets hurt next year. I - tky21 - 9:21pm 11/24/22
- Whatever options that might actually exist in the transfer portal might not even be worth pursuing. - b2runn - 8:29pm 11/24/22
- Buchner is an injury risk, Pyne isn't a starter, that leaves Angeli and Minchey. - iairishcheeks - 7:22pm 11/24/22
- I agree with this. Only thing we don't know is how good Angeli is. Buchner is an injury risk and - tky21 - 7:45pm 11/24/22
- “Buchner threw well” is the unpopular opinion [NT]
- holybull101 - 6:57pm 11/24/22
- Buchner threw well. No problem with his arm. Terrible protection, no running game, bad - tky21 - 7:16pm 11/24/22
- You know what they say about excuses... [NT] - oldirish - 9:54pm 11/24/22
- if he had great touch on the long ball, ND would have beaten Marshall and Styles would have had a TD - WestCoastIrishFan - 8:46pm 11/24/22
- Geez a lot of long passes by pros and good college quarterbacks are missed long and short. Not as - THEISMANCARR - 11:11am 11/25/22
- I said he "showed great touch on the deep ball." I didn't say he was automatic. The throw to Lenzy - tky21 - 9:07pm 11/24/22
- Admit it, you have a thing for him - WoodstockIrish - 6:35am 11/25/22
- Is there another Buchner on the team? - WoodstockIrish - 7:58pm 11/24/22
- Some things are debate-able, some things are not. The velocity he can put on throws is excellent. [NT]
- tky21 - 9:09pm 11/24/22
- Your boy crush is getting embarrassing - WoodstockIrish - 6:37am 11/25/22
- Forget velocity, look at his play and his stats, this year and last year. Underwhelming at best. [NT]
- NDQuebec - 12:22am 11/25/22
- He has the abilities is the point. He can see and has an arm that can make the throws. Any FBS QB - tky21 - 12:45pm 11/26/22
- Here are his stats this year [NT] [LINK] - NDQuebec - 12:22am 11/25/22
- Some things are debate-able, some things are not. The velocity he can put on throws is excellent. [NT]
- tky21 - 9:09pm 11/24/22
- It sounds like we have the next John Elway, I’m sold, 12-0 [NT]
- holybull101 - 7:36pm 11/24/22
- If he can stay healthy, maybe 12-0. If Angeli is ready to be a good QB2 behind Buchner, I'm fine - tky21 - 7:40pm 11/24/22
- Buchner threw well. No problem with his arm. Terrible protection, no running game, bad - tky21 - 7:16pm 11/24/22
- It comes down to this: Pyne is not a starter and simply cannot be the #2 next year. The staff is ex - tky21 - 6:53pm 11/24/22
- You've now progressed well past die on this hill and are on to, die on this mountain range. [NT] - oldirish - 9:56pm 11/24/22
- How is it you know so much about Buchner but somehow know nothing about Buchner - WoodstockIrish - 8:02pm 11/24/22
- Nothing about my post indicates that I "know so much" about Buchner. [NT]
- tky21 - 9:02pm 11/24/22
- Seriously, you literally are fawning all over him and act like you are there with him at practice - WoodstockIrish - 6:40am 11/25/22
- We've not seen Angeli. We've seen Buchner last year and this year and he easily won the QB - tky21 - 5:00pm 11/25/22
- Ok, we agree about one thing.. We’ve seen Buchner, but we haven’t seen Angeli - WoodstockIrish - 5:04pm 11/25/22
- We've not seen Angeli. We've seen Buchner last year and this year and he easily won the QB - tky21 - 5:00pm 11/25/22
- Seriously, you literally are fawning all over him and act like you are there with him at practice - WoodstockIrish - 6:40am 11/25/22
- Nothing about my post indicates that I "know so much" about Buchner. [NT]
- tky21 - 9:02pm 11/24/22
- That sounds like 3 losses [NT]
- holybull101 - 6:59pm 11/24/22
- I don't really know what this means. [NT] - tky21 - 7:18pm 11/24/22
- Re: Unpopular opinion - ND should forego a transfer portal QB - primo - 6:10pm 11/24/22