But my point is that you can still hit on 3*s.

Home > Forums > Football Message Board

| Register

But my point is that you can still hit on 3*s.

Author: iairishcheeks (28845 Posts - Original UHND Member)

Posted at 2:29 pm on May 8, 2023

View All

And the coaches should be doing their own evaluations, star system is for fans.

Replies to: "But my point is that you can still hit on 3*s."

Discussion about the wisdom of offering recruits with less than four star composite ratings - Mark - 11:21am 5/8/23 (30) [View All]
- Re: Discussion about the wisdom of offering recruits with less than four star composite ratings - IrishChristopher - 10:41pm 5/9/23
- Re: Discussion about the wisdom of offering recruits with less than four star composite ratings - NDIrish1988 - 12:52pm 5/8/23
  - Have you paid any attention to ND FB over the last 25 years? - jabbadoody5 - 2:50pm 5/8/23
    - Re: Have you paid any attention to ND FB over the last 25 years? - NDIrish1988 - 3:29pm 5/8/23
      - First you were crying about offering a 3-star, now it's 4-stars - Chrisb - 7:37pm 5/8/23
      - It's literally the best predictor of success in CFB. [NT] - jabbadoody5 - 5:28pm 5/8/23
  - It could easily be the coach not doing his job or not doing it well. [NT] - faircatchcorby - 1:27pm 5/8/23
- Beyond silly to get worked up over this - Nigel Tufnel - 12:48pm 5/8/23
  - Re: Beyond silly to get worked up over this - NDIrish1988 - 12:50pm 5/8/23
- I would think star ratings are more accurate over large - ndphysics - 12:34pm 5/8/23
  - Some are media hype jobs but usually 4-5 star talent turn into draft picks - Rocketman84 - 2:40pm 5/8/23
    - That’s very true over hundreds of kids but there - ndphysics - 5:14pm 5/8/23
- If the coaching staff has done its homework and knows its stuff, I'm fine with it - ndunabomber - 12:17pm 5/8/23
  - Re: If the coaching staff has done its homework and knows its stuff, I'm fine with it - NDIrish1988 - 12:45pm 5/8/23
    - See Clemson 2016. [NT] - iairishcheeks - 2:33pm 5/8/23
- This year's draft... - Zander - 11:57am 5/8/23
- Thanks for taking that crap down. [NT] - BaronVonZemo - 11:41am 5/8/23
  - Ditto. [NT] - Frankx - 11:42am 5/8/23
- Mahomes and Allen were 3*s. - iairishcheeks - 11:29am 5/8/23
  - Name me the last team that won the NC whose roster wasn't composed of 5/4* recruits. [NT] - IrishChristopher - 12:02am 5/10/23
  - Re: Mahomes and Allen were 3*s. - NDIrish1988 - 12:46pm 5/8/23
    - But my point is that you can still hit on 3*s. - iairishcheeks - 2:29pm 5/8/23
      - Re: But my point is that you can still hit on 3*s. - NDIrish1988 - 3:30pm 5/8/23
        UGA took 4 3*s last cycle and 8 the cycle before. - iairishcheeks - 5:12pm 5/8/23
        Practice team. [NT] - whatsamataU - 8:57pm 5/8/23
  - Mahomes and Allen were 3 sport guys who many thought would play Baseball... - Rocketman84 - 12:17pm 5/8/23
    - Good point. [NT] - whatsamataU - 1:08pm 5/8/23
      - It's like when I was being recruited and always missed camps due to AAU Track or Basketball - Rocketman84 - 7:27pm 5/8/23

Consent Management