That would be fine except that there is no current leader in the two big conferences

| Register

That would be fine except that there is no current leader in the two big conferences

Author: Irish_Demon (2753 Posts - Original UHND Member)

Posted at 4:15 pm on Nov 4, 2024

View All

So, yes in order to pick one to put in the top 4 seeds, the committee would have to make huge assumptions. It would just be so much simpler to merely rank the teams the way the committee has always done. I don't know how they will do it. I'm stating how I would like them to do it

Replies to: "That would be fine except that there is no current leader in the two big conferences"

ND's playoff resume took a hit yesterday. - AlbanyIRISH - 5:55am 11/3/24 (33) [View All]
- All we need to worry about is the team winning out which is no lock at all. - Frank L - 11:55am 11/3/24
- First Playoff Seed Prediction: 1. OR 2. GA 3. MIA 4. BYU 5. Tosu 6. TX 7. Tenn 8. ND 9. PSU 10. SMU - Chrisb - 10:16am 11/3/24
  - B10 may get four with a one loss Indiana. Surprised if they don't Only loss would be OSU. [NT] - irishsmashmouth - 8:40pm 11/3/24
  - Pretty good, but I think PSU and Indiana will be before ND. ND 11th. [NT] - NDQuebec - 5:55pm 11/3/24
  - Tenn. and Georgia play each other. [NT] - bill rekles - 2:16pm 11/3/24
    - Does LSU play Alabama? I think Brian will show up for that one if they do. [NT] - THEISMANCARR - 9:15am 11/4/24
    - I know...this wasn't meant a a prediction of the final, just the initial. [NT] - Chrisb - 5:21pm 11/3/24
  - Just one nit - Nigel Tufnel - 12:24pm 11/3/24
    - Re: Just one nit [NT] - irishsmashmouth - 8:34pm 11/3/24
      - * [NT] - irishsmashmouth - 8:36pm 11/3/24
    - Re: Just one nit [NT] - irishsmashmouth - 8:34pm 11/3/24
    - agree, as I stated below [NT] - Irish_Demon - 2:03pm 11/3/24
    - Considering that they exist for only one reason - Chrisb - 1:18pm 11/3/24
      - Kind of disagree, Chris - Irish_Demon - 2:03pm 11/3/24
        I don't think there needs to be any assumptions.. - Chrisb - 2:22pm 11/4/24
        That would be fine except that there is no current leader in the two big conferences - Irish_Demon - 4:15pm 11/4/24
  - Here's mine: Playoff Seed Prediction: 1. OR 2. GA 3. MIA 4. BYU 5. Tosu 6. TX 7. Tenn 8. PSU - AlbanyIRISH - 11:52am 11/3/24
    - I don't see there being any 2 loss teams in initial release.. - Chrisb - 1:14pm 11/3/24
    - I think IU beats OSU and faces Oregon [NT] - MarkHarman - 12:20pm 11/3/24
      - That would be great. [NT] - AlbanyIRISH - 12:50pm 11/3/24
- At this point if we just win out we will be fine [NT] - McIrish - 10:10am 11/3/24
- We need all the top teams to win out and win conference titles. - ndphysics - 6:59am 11/3/24
- Nice prediction - WoodstockIrish - 6:55am 11/3/24
  - Clemson and Pitt are clearly posers. - AlbanyIRISH - 7:41am 11/3/24
- a lot still goes comes down to the eye test. PSU and Texas have no wins close to ND’s. [NT] - WestCoastIrishFan - 6:38am 11/3/24
  - PSU and Texas have no losses close to ND's loss. [NT] - SteveM - 6:44am 11/3/24
    - TX deserves to be ahead, but for the record their best win is Vandy...PSU only quality win is - Chrisb - 1:28pm 11/3/24
      - I heard talking heads today lauding PSU's schedule. - AlbanyIRISH - 1:59pm 11/3/24
        Oh, those 4 or 5 loss teams. [NT] - Chrisb - 5:19pm 11/3/24
    - Gosh, I forgot all about that - Nigel Tufnel - 8:02am 11/3/24
    - Ultimately this is our greatest risk. And we can’t complain if we don’t make it as a result . [NT] - ndphysics - 7:08am 11/3/24
      - And the perception of being Independent. [NT] - whatsamataU - 9:52am 11/3/24
      - a loss is a loss. it’s more about wins. ND will have an easier time getting in at 11-1 thanif it’s - WestCoastIrishFan - 8:33am 11/3/24