Whoever wrote that ""article"" is a complete idiot...committee ranking is exactly the opposite

Author: Chrisb (16649 Posts - Original UHND Member)

Posted at 2:32 pm on Nov 13, 2024

View All

of what they are saying.

Did you not see all the "experts" predicting both Bama and Ol Miss to jump ND..?

The committee had none of it...they are being perfectly fair to ND and we are right where we should be at the moment.

And if Tenn falls to Georgia and then Indiana falls to Tosu, we'll be at the #7 seed right where we should be...with a "chance" at the 6 seed depending how some other things go.

Couldn't be more fair...I'm highly impressed with the playoff committee at this point.

"Leave No Doubt." -Marcus Freeman

Replies to: “Whoever wrote that ""article"" is a complete idiot...committee ranking is exactly the opposite”

Sure seems like the committee is going to screw over Notre Dame based on latest CFP rankings, [NT] [LINK] - whatsamataU - 2:13pm 11/13/24 (13) [View All]
- A better system would be to guarantee the 4 conf champs get in & host a home game but seed by rank - jrdjr84 - 2:45pm 11/13/24
  - An even better system would be just like it is now for Conf Champs getting bye, but seed by rank. [NT] - Chrisb - 2:47pm 11/13/24
    - So, a 10, 11 or 12 seed could get a bye? Interesting. [NT] - jrdjr84 - 8:11pm 11/13/24
      - Yeah, the bye would go to conference champion, but byes wouldn't be locked in to 1-4 seed - Chrisb - 8:48pm 11/13/24
- The CFP committee sees very good SEC/Big10 teams duking it out while ND sashays to 11 & a very bad 1 [NT] - SteveM - 2:34pm 11/13/24
  - Yes, this is precisely why the Playoff Committee has only TX and Tenn (both 1 loss teams) above ND.. - Chrisb - 2:43pm 11/13/24
    - If ND was scheduled against the 2-loss SEC teams at a neutral site who would get the points? - SteveM - 4:59pm 11/13/24
      - Please tell me what on God's green earth a Vegas line has to do with CFP committee rankings? - Chrisb - 5:10pm 11/13/24
        
        CFP rankings are subjective. Why wouldn't CFP ranking logic reflect the wisdom of the crowds? [NT] - SteveM - 5:33pm 11/13/24
        
        CFP rankings are done by a committee who parses over tons of quantitative data to determine - Chrisb - 5:45pm 11/13/24
- Whoever wrote that ""article"" is a complete idiot...committee ranking is exactly the opposite - Chrisb - 2:32pm 11/13/24
- You lose to Northern Illinois, you have no one to blame but yourself. - Clem - 2:18pm 11/13/24
  - Assuming we win next three pray we don’t embarass ourselves - WoodstockIrish - 6:02pm 11/13/24

Consent Management