If Carr gets the nod and he's truly as good as everyone says, unless he gets injured, Minchey's career as a QB is over. I can't see him staying at ND knowing that. My belief is that Minchey gets the start. He fits the Denbrock mold and I think it's an easier sell to get Carr to wait his turn than to tell Minchey he's done and go into 2025 without a backup QB.
Replies to: "Re: I'll be cheering for him. Great kid! If Minchey bolts, that will be concerning from a depth"
- Angeli in the portal. [NT]
- iairishcheeks - 1:42pm 4/17/25
(45) [View All]
- He will be missed!!! [NT] - Jerseymick - 11:26am 4/21/25
- Good guy. Wish him luck and success. [NT]
- Frank L - 11:37pm 4/17/25
- Great ND man who did what was asked of him [NT] - bobdrake - 10:38am 4/18/25
- He was vastly underrated by many on this board - MarkHarman - 7:32pm 4/17/25
- 100%. [NT] - oldirish - 2:17pm 4/18/25
- I stand by my previous belief, that he could have gotten us to the playoffs - ndunabomber - 8:18pm 4/17/25
- He looked 100x better than Buchner or Pyne [NT]
- holybull101 - 8:26pm 4/17/25
- That's a low bar. - AlbanyIRISH - 8:42pm 4/17/25
- He looked 100x better than Buchner or Pyne [NT]
- holybull101 - 8:26pm 4/17/25
- Wonderful Kid! Great Family! My heart is broken!!! [NT]
- irishslovak - 6:41pm 4/17/25
- I hope that he becomes the greatest Volunteer since Davy Crockett.... [NT] - irishslovak - 11:37pm 4/17/25
- Love the guy, good luck bud. [NT] - Frankx - 6:40pm 4/17/25
- Best of luck to him. - AlbanyIRISH - 6:17pm 4/17/25
- He was right where he wanted to be. Hats off to him. [NT] - faircatchcorby - 4:37pm 4/17/25
- Wishing him well. He did what was needed when it was needed. The value of that - LanceManion - 4:21pm 4/17/25
- I'll be cheering for him, regardless of landing spot, next yr. [NT]
- brian irish - 3:26pm 4/17/25
- What is he goes to Boston College? [NT] - AlbanyIRISH - 6:43pm 4/17/25
- Re: I'll be cheering for him, regardless of landing spot, next yr. - EXCEPT IF HE GOES TO PED STATE! [NT]
- NEPA Irish - 3:52pm 4/17/25
- Isn’t Allar returning to Penn State? [NT]
- murph78 - 4:21pm 4/17/25
- Yes. [NT] - AlbanyIRISH - 6:43pm 4/17/25
- Even if he goes to Penn State, I'll still root for him - ndunabomber - 3:54pm 4/17/25
- Isn’t Allar returning to Penn State? [NT]
- murph78 - 4:21pm 4/17/25
- When does he graduate? - IdahoIrish - 3:22pm 4/17/25
- End of this semester. - ndunabomber - 3:42pm 4/17/25
- Good for him. [NT] - whatsamataU - 3:54pm 4/17/25
- End of this semester. - ndunabomber - 3:42pm 4/17/25
- Thank you for all you did for ND and good luck at your next opportunity! [NT] - michiganirish - 3:15pm 4/17/25
- #StarttheCarr [NT] - McIrish - 3:06pm 4/17/25
- Someone will be very lucky to have him. We definitely were. [NT] - jakers - 2:35pm 4/17/25
- Is it minchey or Carr? Or does this mean it’s not Angeli. - ndphysics - 2:06pm 4/17/25
- Pretty much means Angeli is not qb1 - D2 - 2:51pm 4/17/25
- Yep. Same move as Tyler Buchner when it became clear Hartman was QB1. Can't blame either... - TakethetrainKnute - 2:54pm 4/17/25
- I wonder if they move Buchner back to QB as QB4? - ndunabomber - 3:48pm 4/17/25
- And interesting "back-pocket" option. - jakers - 4:49pm 4/17/25
- I wonder if they move Buchner back to QB as QB4? - ndunabomber - 3:48pm 4/17/25
- Yep. Same move as Tyler Buchner when it became clear Hartman was QB1. Can't blame either... - TakethetrainKnute - 2:54pm 4/17/25
- Pretty much means Angeli is not qb1 - D2 - 2:51pm 4/17/25
- A Great ND man. - ndunabomber - 2:02pm 4/17/25
- I'll be cheering for him. Great kid! If Minchey bolts, that will be concerning from a depth - jray - 2:02pm 4/17/25
- Re: I'll be cheering for him. Great kid! If Minchey bolts, that will be concerning from a depth - Zander - 10:27pm 4/17/25
- If the coaches believe it's Carr, they are not going to start Minchey with the thought that Carr is - Irish_Demon - 2:57pm 4/18/25
- Minchey won't. They will develop a red zone package for him. [NT]
- weisguy19 - 3:23pm 4/17/25
- Speculation. [NT] - ELP - 7:24pm 4/18/25
- Plus now he should get some playing time. [NT] - whatsamataU - 3:52pm 4/17/25
- Re: I'll be cheering for him. Great kid! If Minchey bolts, that will be concerning from a depth - Zander - 10:27pm 4/17/25
- A Great ND man. - ndunabomber - 2:02pm 4/17/25
- Understandable. He deserves to play. [NT]
- Hensou - 2:00pm 4/17/25
- Indeed! [NT] - ghostwriter - 2:30pm 4/17/25
- To emerge in Tennessee...? [NT]
[IMAGE]
- TakethetrainKnute - 1:53pm 4/17/25
- He doesn't really fit their offense - D2 - 7:02pm 4/17/25
- All of the best to Steve. A great ND man. [NT]
- BaronVonZemo - 1:43pm 4/17/25
- 100% agreed. Wish him nothing but the best. [NT] - Chris94 - 1:53pm 4/17/25