I wouldn't take that list too seriously. Those are 12 biased sportswriters compiling a list of their personal preferences.
Besides, such an "all time" list that doesn't include Ross Browner on it is something I simply discard.
A voter roster of 12 sportswriters
Replies to: "A voter roster of 12 sportswriters"
- The AP All Time All America Team is a complete joke. - Hensou - 7:42pm 8/14/25
(19) [View All]
- No Ross Browner? [NT] - murph92675 - 1:18pm 8/15/25
- Tebow and Fitzgerald as 1st Teamers??? Of all time??? - jakers - 11:51am 8/15/25
- I think a recency bias argument based on one year could be made for Fitz. [LINK] - iairishcheeks - 12:10pm 8/15/25
- It's the list someone with passing familiarity with the sport might make based on name recognition. [LINK]
- LanceManion - 4:58am 8/15/25
- It's very subjective. I think they got the RBs right at least. - iairishcheeks - 11:36am 8/15/25
- I don't think they got that right either. You're right about subjectivity - Irish_Demon - 12:18pm 8/15/25
- Staubach. Aaron Donald. Rocket. [NT] - Hensou - 12:37pm 8/15/25
- The criteria is not clear, is it best season or best career? - iairishcheeks - 12:22pm 8/15/25
- Very true. In fact... - Irish_Demon - 12:38pm 8/15/25
- I think they turfed it to ChatGPT. [NT]
- LanceManion - 11:43am 8/15/25
- I had the same thought actually, "this looks like an AI summary". [NT]
- iairishcheeks - 12:01pm 8/15/25
- I ran it on chatGPT, and there's a decent amount of overlap. Sings point to AI. Lazy!!! [NT] - LanceManion - 12:35pm 8/15/25
- I had the same thought actually, "this looks like an AI summary". [NT]
- iairishcheeks - 12:01pm 8/15/25
- I don't think they got that right either. You're right about subjectivity - Irish_Demon - 12:18pm 8/15/25
- I would be curious of the age of the voters. This would make a difference - ndphysics - 9:55am 8/15/25
- A voter roster of 12 sportswriters - ndunabomber - 8:39am 8/15/25
- Agreeance [NT] - LanceManion - 11:46am 8/15/25
- Agree. Too many greats missing. Tebow? They must be kidding. [NT]
- Hensou - 8:29am 8/15/25
- Yeah. The list got some right (Hershel Walker) but a lot wrong (Tebow) [NT] - LanceManion - 11:45am 8/15/25
- Where's Johnny Lujack? [NT]
- ELP - 10:39am 8/15/25
- Exactly. 3 NCs [NT] - Hensou - 10:48am 8/15/25
- It's very subjective. I think they got the RBs right at least. - iairishcheeks - 11:36am 8/15/25