I vote yes! I’ve seen too many mediocre Heisman winners who won only because they played for undefeated teams.Surely the best back in the country could beat the QB bias if we had no losses.
Replies to: "Great hypothetical: if we were undefeated would Love be the Heisman favorite?"
- Is J Love the best college player in the nation that won't win the Heisman? - ELP - 4:46pm 11/9/25
(9) [View All]
- Well he won't be the first, Rocket and Theismann both should have won. Rocket created the most havoc - THEISMANCARR - 7:35pm 11/9/25
- I feel so. He has scary speed and is stronger than people realize. In the right offense in the NFL, - jray - 7:35pm 11/9/25
- It's hard to beat out the quarterbacks - ndunabomber - 5:05pm 11/9/25
- Especially when they lead teams without two losses [NT]
- murph78 - 5:42pm 11/9/25
- See Jim Plunkett versus Joe Theismann. [NT] - THEISMANCARR - 7:44pm 11/9/25
- Great hypothetical: if we were undefeated would Love be the Heisman favorite? - Curly1918 - 7:25pm 11/9/25
- I think likely. Opening with two losses knocked him out of the conversation at the time...and the - TakethetrainKnute - 9:15am 11/10/25
- He actually had a very good game against Texas A & M. [NT]
- THEISMANCARR - 12:56pm 11/10/25
- Yes he did. Still a victim of the record I fear [NT] - TakethetrainKnute - 2:53pm 11/10/25
- He actually had a very good game against Texas A & M. [NT]
- THEISMANCARR - 12:56pm 11/10/25
- I think likely. Opening with two losses knocked him out of the conversation at the time...and the - TakethetrainKnute - 9:15am 11/10/25
- Especially when they lead teams without two losses [NT]
- murph78 - 5:42pm 11/9/25