where he's basically a game manager who needs to make a play every once in a great while, and not expected to play like Peyton or Eli and win games.
In addition to the mechanics, he's either regressed, or he's not that good in the first place in progressing through reads. He's had three years with playing experience, and shouldn't be falling for defenses changing looks on him.
Link: QB by QBR
By QBR, he's the 57th ranked QB (Carr 10). He would do well in a JJ McCarthy scenario
Replies to: "By QBR, he's the 57th ranked QB (Carr 10). He would do well in a JJ McCarthy scenario"
- Manning really is unimpressive [NT]
- LanceManion - 10:38pm 11/15/25
(14) [View All]
- The masses were sold another bill of goods by the ESPN led sports media - Clem - 7:32am 11/16/25
- He needs better glasses. [NT] - AlbanyIRISH - 6:30am 11/16/25
- He has not performed as well as advertised but I think the whole Texas team is more overrated and - THEISMANCARR - 2:22am 11/16/25
- Sark has never impressed me as a head coach. He's technically competent, BUT seems to lack killer - LanceManion - 5:53am 11/16/25
- He does not read the field. He throws into double coverage - KWIRISH - 11:34pm 11/15/25
- And his receivers know that. Just watch their body language in the huddle and on the sidelines - LanceManion - 5:50am 11/16/25
- it seems about 20% of his passes have zero chance of success, like he is throwing darts at aCarnival - KWIRISH - 7:44am 11/16/25
- And his receivers know that. Just watch their body language in the huddle and on the sidelines - LanceManion - 5:50am 11/16/25
- I was thinking the same thing watching - McIrish - 10:44pm 11/15/25
- His mechanics have gotten sloppy - ndunabomber - 11:37pm 11/15/25
- He puts Sark in a rough spot [NT]
- murph92675 - 10:44pm 11/15/25
- Sark is a Brian Kelly - keep it close and try to win tough games at the end with improbable heroics. - LanceManion - 5:46am 11/16/25
- Absolutely agree. If his name isn’t Manning, not sure he is a Division 1 QB. [NT]
- notredame678 - 10:41pm 11/15/25
- He is a FBS QB, but top tier? - ndunabomber - 11:06pm 11/15/25
- By QBR, he's the 57th ranked QB (Carr 10). He would do well in a JJ McCarthy scenario [LINK] - LanceManion - 5:45am 11/16/25
- He is a FBS QB, but top tier? - ndunabomber - 11:06pm 11/15/25