One guy always seizes immediate control (the guy who is standing and who apparently runs the equipment), and then does all the talking to coach the silent others to a decision that is by no means always evident from the film. There is never any disagreement, push-back, or discussion. It makes me feel like replay should be discarded altogether, and we just go with the on-field calls.
ADVERTISEMENT
Replies to: "Exactly right. The group dynamics in the replay room are really disturbing:"
- If ND is kicked off the playoff... - AlbanyIRISH - 7:52am 12/5/25
(13) [View All]
- No ND, No Cali team, No PSU (NE fans) No TV ratings! [NT]
- irishslovak - 9:12am 12/5/25
- The nation is salivating to watch Tulane, North Texas or James Madison be sacrificial lambs. [NT]
- Curly1918 - 10:05am 12/5/25
- Root for Duke. Let’s watch it all burn! [NT] - LanceManion - 10:53am 12/5/25
- The nation is salivating to watch Tulane, North Texas or James Madison be sacrificial lambs. [NT]
- Curly1918 - 10:05am 12/5/25
- Irish fans would certainly be frosted. [NT] - TakethetrainKnute - 9:04am 12/5/25
- I love the pop-tarts bowl especially when they murder the pop-tart, BUT - LanceManion - 8:18am 12/5/25
- What's the difference? We will be missing key players. They will be missing key players. - ELP - 8:41am 12/5/25
- Well done Emerson. [NT]
- hipND - 9:14am 12/5/25
- Here's hoping we get Welcomed back to The Show... (...and don't have to go jump in a Lake.) [NT]
- TakethetrainKnute - 9:44am 12/5/25
- Leaving the Irish out would be Karn Evil. [NT]
- hipND - 10:26am 12/5/25
- Indeed. We should still be...9! [NT] - TakethetrainKnute - 10:37am 12/5/25
- Leaving the Irish out would be Karn Evil. [NT]
- hipND - 10:26am 12/5/25
- Here's hoping we get Welcomed back to The Show... (...and don't have to go jump in a Lake.) [NT]
- TakethetrainKnute - 9:44am 12/5/25
- Have you seen how the ACC shows its "situation room" where replays are reviewed? It's intended to - LanceManion - 9:03am 12/5/25
- Yes, in the NCAA, that A doesn’t stand for academic - NDWisconsin - 12:00pm 12/5/25
- Exactly right. The group dynamics in the replay room are really disturbing: - murph78 - 11:17am 12/5/25
- Well done Emerson. [NT]
- hipND - 9:14am 12/5/25
- What's the difference? We will be missing key players. They will be missing key players. - ELP - 8:41am 12/5/25
- No ND, No Cali team, No PSU (NE fans) No TV ratings! [NT]
- irishslovak - 9:12am 12/5/25
Consent Management