First post...better make it good.
"Notre Dame, buoyed by transfers, knocks Georgia out of CFP"
TL;DR: First off, this headline triggered me. It oozes with sore-loser jealousy. Anyone who has followed ND all season would know that this wasn’t just a showing of transfer stars; these stars have also had their struggles all season. Getting to where we are right now has been a massive team effort, buoyed by so many players that were recruited by and/or developed by ND.
But my full take is this:
As NIL and the transfer portal started really getting going prior to this season, we all shouted that this was the end of college football as we know it. We were right. But, lucky us, we seem to be playing the first round of this new era better than a lot of teams.
This isn’t just the players – we have a coach who is using so many strategic tactics that I’ve never seen that, when they happen, we fans can see what he’s trying to lure the opposition into…and it works. So many times this season, I’ve been watching the game and will say out loud, “wait, he’s trying to …” and then it works. Case in point, drawing GA offsides on 4 & 1 with a special teams switcheroo and a delayed snap.
Long-term, I think the current NIL/portal setup will be bad for smaller programs – they will likely have to work incredibly hard to keep stars they’ve developed from transferring out. I’m very curious to see what these teams will do to incentivize players to stick around in the future. Perhaps there is plenty of room for these programs to grow and eventually become larger programs themselves, but we’ll have to wait to see that. I, like many ND fans, am a non-alumnus fan who would love to see my random state school alma mater eventually have a successful football team, but for now I don’t see that happening.
In the current season and state of NIL/portal, I 100% thought that UGA, Bama, OSU, um, etc. would just be able to snowball their programs by dumping money into their roster and keep their crazy depth. Depth I’ve dreamed about for YEARS.
Instead, it’s leveling the playing field. For once, all the depth in the NCAA isn’t warming some big-program bench. Talent is being distributed to teams, and coaches can coach and build teams. A player isn’t going to just wait his turn behind two others in Nowhere, USA so that he has a chance to shine one day. Some school that doesn’t have $20mm but has $2mm is going to say, “come play for us NOW and SHINE”.
Last night was a good night. I absolutely lost my mind. I’m not saying we will win out. But we have a chance. We just got respect. Today, the SEC fanboys/girls will be claiming injuries took away real UGA (look at our injuries!!). But we all know Carson Beck was not going to take GA all the way. Gunner Stockton is going to be good. He doesn’t have the reps yet, but he’ll be a force next year. Still, we beat the SEC school that analysts (esp. Paul Whine-baum) were saying was going to win it all.
If you’re an SEC team that watched last night’s game and thought anything other than ‘Damn. Maybe Notre Dame isn’t overrated.’, you’re a denier who can’t see past your SEC goggles. And maybe the SEC should stop looking at their inbred schedule that is fluffed with just as many easy games as we all have.
I'm pumped. Bring on PSU. GO IRISH. BEAT NITTANY LIONS.
Link: https://www.espn.com/college-football/story/_/id/43266364/notre-dame-buoyed-transfers-knocks-georgia-cfp
Every scholarship portal guy we brought in this year contributed meaningfully to the team.
What was more impressive, though, was putting in all of that young talent (quite a few freshmen and sophomores played a lot of minutes this year) and putting out that level of performance.
The position coaches have done a great job of getting players ready for the most part.
Joe Rudolph worked some real miracles this year, putting forth a decent offensive line out of 2nd and 3rd stringers when all of those injuries robbed us of our best prospective players. To have an undersized, 3 star true freshman starting at left tackle all year long, and holding his own, is quite remarkable.
Mike Mickens had Leonard Moore seamlessly stepping in for Ben Morrison, to the point where I don't see any dropoff with Moore in there. He's doing just fine covering WR1's on the boundary side. That, plus he has a true sophomore (Adon Shuler) playing safety and doing a fine job.
Al Washington helped get a lot of defensive linemen ready to play, and that even after the boatload of injuries, still has them playing at a high level.
Max Bullough's linebacker corps looks deep and talented.
Gino Guidugli helped Riley Leonard get caught up, and Leonard become more than just a "look for WR1 and take off running" QB. No, he's not a precision pocket passer, but he definitely improved throughout the season.
that your first two sentences is what I was trying to say in my opener. 100% agree.