I'm a litigator by profession and, during my time as an attorney, there have been occasions where I have been royally and maliciously screwed by trial judges, appellate courts, court administrators, and opposing counsel. There have been plenty of times where, when standing in front of a jury while listening to the judge make a devastatingly bad ruling that kills my case, I have wanted to tell the honorable nincompoop - on the record - just where they can stick their judicial wisdom. But I don't.
Dropping a nuke is often a surefire way to hurt my clients in the long run.
Lots of ND fans suggest that Pete - an ND grad, by the way - should throw a fit. He could tell off the ACC, ESPN, the Committee, and all the haters. He should cancel contracts. Cancel games. Make sweeping declarations about how unfair this all was and how corrupt all these bad actors are. Doing so would feel good for us, the Irish faithful, and we would feel righteous as we burn it all around us.
But then what? What happen when the next committee gets told that a 12-0 ND team needs to be ranked 14th so as to just miss the playoff. What happens when the ACC shifts their schedule around to deny us normally good matchups (Clemson, Florida State, Miami, Va Tech) in favor of the usual ACC trash? What happens when ESPN goes to war - feeling slighted and defensive - and begins a nonstop campaign against ND in an effort to sway recruits away? Yes, I know that the committee and the ACC and ESPN are already doing these things - quietly - but their efforts will become far more loud and aggressive if we drop the nuke.
I suspect that Pete is attempting to make peace, make friends, and develop positive relationships. He's likely keeping notes, though, about who has screwed us the most in case we are ever in a position to repay the favor. But the more "well respected" he is - by not whining like Sark or Cristobal and by not attacking the character of the disingenuous anti-ND crowd that is currently in charge - the more he may be able to steer things in our favor down the road. Things are changing in College Football. They are changing rapidly. Nobody can know just what is to come. Yet if he is able to develop the relationships that will allow him to guide ND through the troubled waters ahead, that will - in the long run - be far more desirable than wailing and gnashing teeth now.
We were screwed. No doubt about it. Next year, let's win all our games and pay back the haters. But to those who are being hyper critical of our Athletic Director and suggesting that his perceived passivity and lack of world-shaking pronouncements is a sign that he isn't working on behalf of the University, please remember that caution and diplomacy might be the safest way to protect Irish interests in the long term.
Go Irish
Swarbrick would have rolled over and ask to have his stomach petted.
And that fight should be directed at eliminating the ACC connection and towards an FCS style playoff format while maintaining independence.
He can take the Sun Tzu route if he likes. Even so, there is some merit in exposing untoward tactics to the public eye or they will raise their insidious heads again.
Maybe the NCAA committee needs an ethics board and needs to make public and/or televise the discussions.
Miami's biggest game in 10 years was the game earlier this year against ND.
But beyond that, ND no longer has an exclusive media contract. It doesn't have a state backing it up. It doesn't have 50,000 students. Etc.
So, have to play the cards ND has and play them as well as we can. As much as I hated Swarbrick, I think he was effective at the back room stuff. Pete, less so. But, that's not to say he's bad at his job.
He played this perfectly. Going ballistic would have solved nothing in the long term.
help anyone, as you've pointed out.
But PB did need to come out much stronger in support of his troops. He came off as weak and the whole "this won't happen again, they promised" is even more lame.
I get why CMF didn't make a statement right away, he probably would've gone nuclear.
In my business as a SVP for a global financial management company, the same sort of things have happened to me with different circumstances. I always live for another day … and, my memory is very, very good, as is yours. I paid someone back big time who tried to nail me over 30 years ago. I am Italian, lol. Aloha, Mike
On another topic, I believe this NIL deal, is going to be the end of college sports as we used to remember them. My two cents …
(no message)
Disney executives? Conference commissioners?
Today, both told him to pound sand and that you’re not worth what you think you are.
And we’ll move on without your eyeballs.
Good luck w Peacock.
So their commissioner maybe. Though ally seems to strong a word. More like having aligned goals in the short term. Like the USA and Russia in WWII. Once it's over they'll want to nuke us again.
(no message)
Well said good sir.
May the road rise to meet you,
May the wind be always at your back,
May the sun shine warm upon your face,
The rains fall soft upon your fields,
And until we meet again,
May God hold you in the palm of His hand.
I think what we saw today was the domino that the CFB world needed to realize that the current parameters are utter bullshit.
How dare this committee rob these kids of the opportunity to prove themselves.
It feels like the CFB landscape is scared of a dominant ND run, of which is inevitable under CMF.
Consent Management