I have always argued that the Babe was the best player ever

Author: Chris94 (38699 Posts - Original UHND Member)

Posted at 5:25 pm on May 5, 2026

View All

Ohtani can pass him. Another few years of what he is doing now will seal it.

Waiting for you to tell me who is better in the last 100 years. Since Ruth.

Replies to: “I have always argued that the Babe was the best player ever”

I can't imagine what Babe Ruth's stats would be like if he was granted the same privileges as Ohtani - Hensou - 4:36pm 5/5/26 (27) [View All]
- Good topic, good discussion - Mark - 8:50pm 5/5/26
- It’s hard to compare the different eras… - justknox - 6:40pm 5/5/26
  - Indeed. Yes, Fat Babe was well over 215. - Hensou - 7:04pm 5/5/26
- Can't agree here, my friend. But imagine if Ohtani were allowed to play golf w 52 clubs in his bag! [NT] - BaronVonZemo - 4:52pm 5/5/26
  - What is your disagreement based on? [NT] - Hensou - 4:54pm 5/5/26
    - Two things.... - BaronVonZemo - 4:59pm 5/5/26
      - For the majority of his career Ruth was 6 '2" and 215 pounds. - Hensou - 5:05pm 5/5/26
        
        I was adding more to my post - sry. But that is a fair point-it'd be like judging Bird from his last - BaronVonZemo - 5:16pm 5/5/26
        
        The only minority player who was Ruth's equal was Josh Gibson - Hensou - 5:24pm 5/5/26
        
        The point is not to find an equal to Ruth - Chris94 - 5:30pm 5/5/26
        
        Ask Satchel, Oscar, Buck, etc. - Hensou - 5:37pm 5/5/26
        
        No one said that anyone was [NT] - Chris94 - 5:52pm 5/5/26
        
        You suggested MLB was weaker without Black players. I suggest Ruth would still dominate. [NT] - Hensou - 6:06pm 5/5/26
        
        No, I suggest that any "privilege" that Ohtani has is outweighed by those Ruth had [NT] - Chris94 - 7:09pm 5/5/26
        
        You seem to be arguing with yourself. - Hensou - 7:31pm 5/5/26
- His numbers would have been the same - Chris94 - 4:45pm 5/5/26
  - He truly is a phenom. So much so that MLB looked the other way on the gambling issue- - BaronVonZemo - 4:57pm 5/5/26
  - That is not logical. It is not correct. - Hensou - 4:53pm 5/5/26
    - I love the Babe. But the game is much harder today. - Chris94 - 4:57pm 5/5/26
      - Ruth stopped pitching because he wanted to play everyday. To do that he had to play the field. - Hensou - 5:17pm 5/5/26
        
        I have always argued that the Babe was the best player ever - Chris94 - 5:25pm 5/5/26
        
        Babe played his late game in 1935. 91 years ago. Look at his 1927 stats. 99 years ago. - Hensou - 5:33pm 5/5/26
        
        Sorry - I thought "100 years" obviously meant "since Ruth" [NT] - Chris94 - 6:03pm 5/5/26
        
        Please say what you mean and mean what you say. Otherwise, we take you at face value. [NT] - Hensou - 6:10pm 5/5/26
        
        Also, as I mentioned above, Ohtani never faced pitchers from the higher mound which is a big deal - BaronVonZemo - 5:21pm 5/5/26
        
        Here's a neat side story. [NT] [LINK] - Hensou - 5:25pm 5/5/26
        
        Great stuff. [NT] - BaronVonZemo - 8:05pm 5/5/26

Consent Management