Do you think the military should be disobeying their orders?

NedoftheHill 47378 posts Joined: Jun 29, 2011

Posted 8:50 pm on Jul 21, 2026

If the Marines were told to take Kharg Island, would you publicly advise them / support them disobeying the orders to do so?

(( As an aside, doesn't "Kharg Island" sound like an evil lair for a Hollywood / Disney evil villain? ))

This message has been edited 1 time(s).

Evil preaches tolerance until it is dominant, then it tries to silence good.

Replies 15

Do you think the military should be disobeying their orders? NedoftheHill 8:50pm · 7/21/26
- No. Next stupid question.NT conorlarkin 8:51pm · 7/21/26
  - You said it is an illegal war. That begged the question. NedoftheHill 8:55pm · 7/21/26
    - Jus ad bellum was violated. Not jus in bello, which covers most illegal orders.NT Chris94 9:12pm · 7/21/26
    - It is an illegal war. conorlarkin 9:01pm · 7/21/26

View Full Conversation