What will 24-team CFP achieve?
It will produce a national champion with little controversy.
It will water down regular season competition further and change the goal of most college programs - winning the season to go the Rose, Sugar, Orange, Fiesta or Cotton bowl on New Year.
It will kill traditional and regional rivalries, one of the most valuable traditions of college football or make their games less interesting. Therefore it will reduce joys and excitement of beating a bitter rivalry or #1 ranked team in a watered-down regular season.
It will ruin festival new year bowls by making them just stepping stones to championship instead an ultimate goal. College bowl institutions superficially preserved, but their soul profoundly lost.
I love college football because of its grassroots charm/energy/passion that associate heavily on regional differences, unique traditions, and localized stakes. Unlike centralized professional sport whose goal is simple, championship. College football is much richer than that. I’ve followed it for 35 years. I know it carries cultural weight more than any other sports in its 150 years history.
But now this ultra-focus on this national title contention CFP, joined by transfer portal, free agency market and NIL will transform college football, a regional/local bowl-centric grassroots pastime into professional-like standardized, nationalized sport, a centralized TV product mirroring NFL. Yes, I believe college football is on the way to become NFL Jr or NFL lite. This is what 24-team CFP will eventually and unfortunately achieve.
That’s a memo.
PS, I post it on OPEN not on Football board because I view college football as a living piece of American culture, history and tradition, not just a game.