You can’t hit a curve ball or drain a 3 point shot just because you are a great athlete. You can see it just by looking at Notre Dame football. How many “freak” athletes have we had who were busts? Plenty. Peyton Manning or Tom Brady aren’t near the athlete that Michael Vick is.
I mentioned my HS soccer team. Those Olympic track athletes (sprinting, long jump, hurdles) were not even close to being the best players on our team. We did have a couple of great players who went on to play college baseball and basketball. The track guys were the best pure athletes, but there was more to it than that.