I own one "dress watch" and one Garmin.

The dress watch is worn to weddings, formal events, etc., so maybe 3-4 times a year. I wear the Garmin 99% of the time - training to track my performance stats/VO2 Max/etc., monitor my sleep and resting pulse, etc. And since it doubles as my alarm clock, it's just convenient to keep it on the majority of the time.

I'm sure you remember TNIrish from the boards back in the day - he was passionate about high-end watches.