Register

Do you believe it is morally defensible for Palsy Putin to nuke Kiev because of this drone attack?

Iggle 13088 posts Joined: Sep 14, 2007

Posted 3:59 pm on Jun 22, 2022

(no message)

Replies 15

Do you believe it is morally defensible for Palsy Putin to nuke Kiev because of this drone attack?NT Iggle 3:59pm · 6/22/22
- I said "on the way to be nuked", i.e. escalating in that direction, yes, Russia will nuke Eli 4:08pm · 6/22/22
  - I asked for your opinion on the moral question.NT Iggle 4:09pm · 6/22/22
    - It depends on proportionality principle that the harms of nuking proportional to the gainsNT Eli 4:44pm · 6/22/22
      - Please give one example of how nuking a city might be morally acceptable Chris94 5:39pm · 6/22/22
        
        Go ahead what? We haven't had nuclear war yet. Ask me later when it happens and we are still aliveNT Eli 7:57pm · 6/22/22
        
        You were asked whether it would ever would be ok to nuke Kiev. Chris94 8:51pm · 6/22/22
        
        Nuking Kiev has NOT happened yet. Of course it depends what's going to happen. Are you saying Eli 9:08pm · 6/22/22
        
        So... Harari makes the argument that nuclear proliferation created lasting peace. iairishcheeks 5:52pm · 6/22/22
        
        Lots of people make that case Chris94 6:26pm · 6/22/22
        
        I think it depends on how willing you are to zoom out. iairishcheeks 7:21pm · 6/22/22

View Full Conversation