In this day and age, players would not stick around for multiple seasons for a coach they don't like. We can form judgments about Shrews, but ultimately the players have to respect him, not us. I watch a lot of sports and have seen a lot of college players get into arguments with their coaches. I haven't seen that once with them towards Shrews, nor have I ever seen the signs of dissension and poor attitudes. Given Shrews' strategy of building the program on four-year guys, this is obviously a significant criterion by which he is evaluated. Job well done, thus far, and particularly when look at Burton, whom any number of high-major programs would welcome as a transfer.
I hope his strategy works, but I'm skeptical. Shaka Smart is employing the same philosophy at Marquette, and as I predicted, it isn't working.