It had nothing to do with what they did to our D when Love went out, and wasn't going to change the outcome of a blowout where they had backups in nearly the entire 4th quarter.
1 - the ball rulled a fumble we recovered on the kickoff that was overturned was definitely a bad reversal as there was nothing to show conclusively the ball touched the sideline and math and angles and what not say a curved ball with only maybe a half inch hanging over the sideline like 99.9% didn't actually touch the sideline.
They got that one wrong.
2 - the Mack catch/drop is debatable...I thought it was a catch and a fumble, but it was close and there was great video angles of it so this isn't a definite they got it wrong, but I think it was wrong so this is where I give you a half.
3 - the Book fumble was absolutely 100% a fumble and Clemson did 100% recover it in a timely manner and Book absolutely 100% can not regain possession of a ball while laying on his back and putting his leg over it...that IS NOT possession and was actually something that happened earlier this year in one of our games but went our way as the other team tried to just lay a body part on the ball and we recovered it.
They got that one correct regardless of what whatshisname said.
Replies to: "I'll give you 1.5 of those and while that may have kept us in it longer.."
- SEC Bowl record of 6-6 was worst of Power 5 other than PAC12. Top SECCG teams both manhandled - BaronVonZemo - 10:33pm 1/8/19
(33) [View All]
- Re: SEC Bowl record of 6-6 was worst of Power 5 other than PAC12. Top SECCG teams both manhandled - mmclaug580 - 3:25pm 1/10/19
- Been saying this for a while.............. - murph92675 - 11:53am 1/9/19
- This is pretty much accurate, but no one will believe it. [NT] - oldirish - 8:18pm 1/9/19
- I will say that they are the best conference but they are not off the charts great. Obviously, - THEISMANCARR - 5:27pm 1/9/19
- Four teams in the Top 10 - WoodstockIrish - 3:08pm 1/9/19
- I think the SEC was strong this season, and is usually the best conference. - Napoleon - 2:57pm 1/9/19
- Won't exactly work for ND. Without the conference championship, ND needs a strong SOS. - TakethetrainKnute - 1:43pm 1/9/19
- Several SEC - WoodstockIrish - 1:23pm 1/9/19
- In fairness, though, ND's weaker SOS was unexpected. - Napoleon - 2:54pm 1/9/19
- Agree - WoodstockIrish - 3:07pm 1/9/19
- In fairness, though, ND's weaker SOS was unexpected. - Napoleon - 2:54pm 1/9/19
- the ACC conference prepared Clemson for the playoffs. [NT]
- DonMiller - 11:23am 1/9/19
- Apparently it half-prepared Notre Dame for the playoffs... [NT] - TakethetrainKnute - 1:00pm 1/9/19
- Exactly, knocking off 6-6 Pittsburgh in the conference championship was a real nail biter for them [NT]
- WoodstockIrish - 11:28am 1/9/19
- But it was mental preparation. Part of the don’t smile to much while kicking their ass training. [NT] - whatsamataU - 5:47pm 1/9/19
- Ironic - WoodstockIrish - 8:59am 1/9/19
- Did anyone here claim what they have? No. [NT] - BaronVonZemo - 9:28am 1/9/19
- Where are the excuses? I see mostly, we are good enough posts - NDNEIL - 9:17am 1/9/19
- Just search on TheismannCarr...and several others but he is the biggest offender - WoodstockIrish - 9:35am 1/9/19
- All I said was if the 3 calls that were overturned were not overturned which they should not have - THEISMANCARR - 10:41am 1/9/19
- What are the 3 calls that shouldn't have been overturned? [NT]
- Chrisb - 4:36pm 1/9/19
- The three calls according to Mike Peralta or Ferrara or whatever his name is - THEISMANCARR - 5:31pm 1/9/19
- I'll give you 1.5 of those and while that may have kept us in it longer.. - Chrisb - 9:47pm 1/9/19
- That seems fair but I wonder if the ball lying prone under Book, similar to a punt that dies - THEISMANCARR - 3:01pm 1/10/19
- The “ review Refs “ were out toget us. Blatant as hell it was.... [NT] - whatsamataU - 5:49pm 1/9/19
- I'll give you 1.5 of those and while that may have kept us in it longer.. - Chrisb - 9:47pm 1/9/19
- The three calls according to Mike Peralta or Ferrara or whatever his name is - THEISMANCARR - 5:31pm 1/9/19
- Says the guy - WoodstockIrish - 11:24am 1/9/19
- Tim Tebow is an idiot, but that's besides the point. [NT] - Chrisb - 4:35pm 1/9/19
- No - WoodstockIrish - 11:21am 1/9/19
- He has a point, and here's why - cubsfanin16 - 1:45pm 1/9/19
- What are the 3 calls that shouldn't have been overturned? [NT]
- Chrisb - 4:36pm 1/9/19
- All I said was if the 3 calls that were overturned were not overturned which they should not have - THEISMANCARR - 10:41am 1/9/19
- Just search on TheismannCarr...and several others but he is the biggest offender - WoodstockIrish - 9:35am 1/9/19
- “Their analysis goes, “refs, turnovers, coaching....but we don’t make excuses”. wow, they must post - whatsamataU - 8:18am 1/9/19
- Come on? Do you really think Alabama wanted to be in that bowl game? [NT]
- NDNEIL - 7:32am 1/9/19
- Lol [NT] - BaronVonZemo - 9:27am 1/9/19
- Check 2018 and 2017 its worse [NT] - murph92675 - 1:05am 1/9/19
- Expect it to continue. [NT] - guiness4everyone - 11:56pm 1/8/19