Regardless of the list and who puts it out it's pretty hard to be considered top 5 or 10 at a position. This also proves the kid has some skill though 90% of this board thinks he stinks.
The proof is in the stats of actual games not in the imagination of these guys' minds and their fantasies about unproductive ex-4 & 5* recruits. This board remembers the one or two plays that wowed them by mostly unpreductive players that were once HS gods. They continually overlook the consistency of execution by the guys that actually produce who may or may not have been highly recruited. Kelly suffers from this same form of brain damage. I wouldn't be shocked to find out one day that Kelly himself was one of these deranged posters.
Replies to: "100%. In true fashion all those guys on this board will claim they always supported Book. Ridiculous"
- I wish national sportswriters & other coaches would listen to this board about how mediocre Book is. [LINK]
- MAS - 8:58pm 5/16/20
(23) [View All]
- Book is an excellent QB and the number 5 rating is pretty right on. But he has to play like 1 or 2 - THEISMANCARR - 9:10pm 5/25/20
- I wish more Notre Dame fans on here would realize what a special quarterback we have in Ian [NT]
- DonMiller - 1:24pm 5/18/20
- Dunno about special, but the shit he takes is unwarranted. I like him. Tough motha - Frank L - 6:48pm 5/18/20
- He has a good head & good speed with limited arm and short height. I suppose that he gets a bit of - BaronVonZemo - 3:26pm 5/17/20
- You're describing Drew Brees.... [NT]
- ripperduck - 10:06pm 5/17/20
- ...or Tommy Rees with more speed. [NT]
- BaronVonZemo - 12:19am 5/18/20
- I've added you to the list. - MAS - 9:52am 5/18/20
- I like Book, and I hope he proves me wrong (really hope), but he’s good not great and - BaronVonZemo - 1:59pm 5/18/20
- Imho he was lousy reading deep routes hope he improves that dramatically I like his moxie and speed. [NT] - Jerseymick - 7:30pm 5/19/20
- I like Book, and I hope he proves me wrong (really hope), but he’s good not great and - BaronVonZemo - 1:59pm 5/18/20
- Book has a significantly stronger arm than Rees ever did - ndunabomber - 9:22am 5/18/20
- I agree, but my real point is that Book is not Drew Brees. [NT]
- BaronVonZemo - 9:43am 5/18/20
- “lacks accuracy and touch on his long throws” and “does not possess the ideal height you look for in - iairishcheeks - 5:07pm 5/18/20
- Exactly. Most of the on paper guys don't pan out. That's what is wrong with scouting. They don't - oldirish - 6:57pm 5/18/20
- According to Wikipedia, Brees has the third highest seasonal qb rating... - ripperduck - 5:49pm 5/18/20
- No argument on that part - ndunabomber - 11:24am 5/18/20
- “lacks accuracy and touch on his long throws” and “does not possess the ideal height you look for in - iairishcheeks - 5:07pm 5/18/20
- I agree, but my real point is that Book is not Drew Brees. [NT]
- BaronVonZemo - 9:43am 5/18/20
- I've added you to the list. - MAS - 9:52am 5/18/20
- ...or Tommy Rees with more speed. [NT]
- BaronVonZemo - 12:19am 5/18/20
- You're describing Drew Brees.... [NT]
- ripperduck - 10:06pm 5/17/20
- Ya see that. You’ve taken posters saying PJ should - jimbasil - 12:43pm 5/17/20
- 100%. In true fashion all those guys on this board will claim they always supported Book. Ridiculous - oldirish - 9:51am 5/17/20
- Speaking of QB talent? QB Taulia Tagovailoa transferring from Bama to Maryland [NT]
- whatsamataU - 8:41am 5/17/20
- That was pretty much a given, though - ndunabomber - 9:23am 5/18/20
- I don’t follow them but appears they are putting together a decent class with transfers and recruits [NT] - whatsamataU - 1:25pm 5/18/20
- That was pretty much a given, though - ndunabomber - 9:23am 5/18/20
- Wow, this kind of affirmation and $1.00 will get you a small premium roast coffee at McDonalds [NT] - humbaba - 2:58am 5/17/20
- I'll say 98% of national sports writer (most of them are bloggers) couldn't evaluate talent their - holybull101 - 10:55pm 5/16/20
- I wasn’t sure where you were going with this. Nice dose - faircatchcorby - 9:43pm 5/16/20