Honestly, no. I would want to see a top recruit actually turn out at ND. I give you Crist. I give

| Register

Honestly, no. I would want to see a top recruit actually turn out at ND. I give you Crist. I give

Author: tky21 (522 Posts - Joined: May 13, 2010)

Posted at 9:40 pm on Mar 31, 2021

View All

you Kiel. I give you Wimbush. I give you Zaire. I give you Kizer. I give you Jurkovek.

We end up with Rees and Book, both of whom I respect and played every bit up to their abilities and were respected leaders. But that list I gave you were all top 250 and 4 star or higher and a lot were top 85 in the country. Al very solid 4 stars at least. All of them seemed to get completely screwed up in one way or the other. So, I'd want to see a top recruit actually turn out for ND.

Bigger question is whether Buchner turns out. For me, I hope so but I'll believe it when I see it. And if he doesn't turn out either, we'll achieve critical mass in the narrative that ND is the university highly rated QB recruits go to get ruined.

Replies to: "Honestly, no. I would want to see a top recruit actually turn out at ND. I give you Crist. I give"

If you were the top rated HS QB and Academically qualified would you go to ND? I would no Questions - Frankx - 4:02pm 3/31/21 (36) [View All]
- I would go to ND or Stanford but there are a lot of Universities where you could get a great ed - CC72 - 6:09pm 4/1/21
  - Myron Rolle at FSU. I think he is a neurosurgeon now. [NT] - NDavenue - 12:53pm 4/2/21
- Easily Clemson. - AlbanyIRISH - 2:16pm 4/1/21
- A smidge off topic..................... - ELP - 9:34am 4/1/21
  - I'm sure. Like ND was, SC, Miami, Nebraska, it's cyclic and right now it's Bama. [NT] - Frankx - 10:06am 4/1/21
- Honestly, no. I would want to see a top recruit actually turn out at ND. I give you Crist. I give - tky21 - 9:40pm 3/31/21
  - Re: Honestly, no. I would want to see a top recruit actually turn out at ND. I give you Crist. I give - Rocketman84 - 5:15am 4/1/21
  - Always wonder if Brandon would have been great in a CJ Procise role. [NT] - ND521 - 12:13am 4/1/21
  - out of your list, Kiel was the only top Kelly recruit - holybull101 - 10:38pm 3/31/21
    - Kelly inherited Crist, though, and didn't do well with him. The ones I mentioned were more highly - tky21 - 11:05pm 3/31/21
      - Crist was okay for a first year starter until his knee got wrecked. Never the same after that. [NT] - ND521 - 12:11am 4/1/21
- I’d go where I felt most comfortable. - Napoleon - 7:59pm 3/31/21
  - Yep, understood. [NT] - Frankx - 11:18pm 3/31/21
- So right now you must be overweight compared to HS, a little on the short side and slightly slow of - whatsamataU - 7:46pm 3/31/21
  - Really, really weak response. Basically, you just won the Lotto - Frankx - 11:21pm 3/31/21
- No. rees is not an elite O coach. [NT] - Aragoto - 7:16pm 3/31/21
  - I'm hoping u r wrong. Hoping. [NT] - Frankx - 11:23pm 3/31/21
- Right now they seem to be going to Clemson, Ohio State, Georgia, and Alabama. Kelly would need to hi - holybull101 - 6:37pm 3/31/21
- Considering the OLine and the rest of the very talented players at ND - Yes - however, knowing - jimbasil - 4:19pm 3/31/21
  - I was thinking about this earlier today, I think BK's mental illness with QBs started with Golson - holybull101 - 6:30pm 3/31/21
    - Well, Rees wasn't mobile, in fact he was the opposite of that and he had no arm - jimbasil - 9:15pm 3/31/21
    - USC’s current QB was a 6’2 180 pound 3* prospect. [NT] - Napoleon - 8:02pm 3/31/21
      - Book - 3* and 5'10" no arm. [NT] - jimbasil - 9:16pm 3/31/21
        Is he 5’10? - Napoleon - 10:12pm 3/31/21
        No way Book is over 5'11". A pal of mine stood next to him in 2019 at some - jimbasil - 10:18pm 3/31/21
        He was measured at 6’0 for NFL observers at his pro day. - Napoleon - 10:26pm 3/31/21
        instead of comparing one or two, look at the QBs over the past decade. - holybull101 - 10:45pm 3/31/21
        Definitley the best way to compare. Most however, pick their favorite two and call that the sample. [NT] - oldirish - 9:35pm 4/1/21
        
        Jurkovec was 6-5. Kizer was 6-4. - Napoleon - 11:01pm 3/31/21
        you're not even being honest listing walk-ons on their roster - holybull101 - 12:07am 4/1/21
        I’m being honest. I just pulled up their 2020 roster and listed the QBs. - Napoleon - 7:41am 4/1/21
        How many 5'9" QBs have you seen play a down; not named Flutie? [NT] - oldirish - 9:37pm 4/1/21
        
        Maybe this will help: starting with the 2012 class, I compared the heights of USC & ND QB recruits. - Napoleon - 9:30am 4/1/21
        Thank you for disproving someone's theory with real facts. We need more of this. [NT] - oldirish - 9:38pm 4/1/21
        
        fine, i just have guys like Book, Golson, Zaire, and Wimbush in my head [NT] - holybull101 - 12:52pm 4/1/21
        I understand. Sorry if I came off as belligerent. - Napoleon - 2:18pm 4/1/21