Honestly, no. I would want to see a top recruit actually turn out at ND. I give you Crist. I give

| Register

Honestly, no. I would want to see a top recruit actually turn out at ND. I give you Crist. I give

Author: tky21 (2636 Posts - Joined: May 13, 2010)

Posted at 9:40 pm on Mar 31, 2021

View All

you Kiel. I give you Wimbush. I give you Zaire. I give you Kizer. I give you Jurkovek.

We end up with Rees and Book, both of whom I respect and played every bit up to their abilities and were respected leaders. But that list I gave you were all top 250 and 4 star or higher and a lot were top 85 in the country. Al very solid 4 stars at least. All of them seemed to get completely screwed up in one way or the other. So, I'd want to see a top recruit actually turn out for ND.

Bigger question is whether Buchner turns out. For me, I hope so but I'll believe it when I see it. And if he doesn't turn out either, we'll achieve critical mass in the narrative that ND is the university highly rated QB recruits go to get ruined.

"Put a Riddell on somebody and be the most physical team in the country until the whistle blows."

Replies to: "Honestly, no. I would want to see a top recruit actually turn out at ND. I give you Crist. I give"

If you were the top rated HS QB and Academically qualified would you go to ND? I would no Questions - Frankx - 4:02pm 3/31/21 (36) [View All]
- I would go to ND or Stanford but there are a lot of Universities where you could get a great ed - CC72 - 6:09pm 4/1/21
  - Myron Rolle at FSU. I think he is a neurosurgeon now. [NT] - NDavenue - 12:53pm 4/2/21
- Easily Clemson. - AlbanyIRISH - 2:16pm 4/1/21
- A smidge off topic..................... - ELP - 9:34am 4/1/21
  - I'm sure. Like ND was, SC, Miami, Nebraska, it's cyclic and right now it's Bama. [NT] - Frankx - 10:06am 4/1/21
- Honestly, no. I would want to see a top recruit actually turn out at ND. I give you Crist. I give - tky21 - 9:40pm 3/31/21
  - Re: Honestly, no. I would want to see a top recruit actually turn out at ND. I give you Crist. I give - Rocketman84 - 5:15am 4/1/21
  - Always wonder if Brandon would have been great in a CJ Procise role. [NT] - ND521 - 12:13am 4/1/21
  - out of your list, Kiel was the only top Kelly recruit - holybull101 - 10:38pm 3/31/21
    - Kelly inherited Crist, though, and didn't do well with him. The ones I mentioned were more highly - tky21 - 11:05pm 3/31/21
      - Crist was okay for a first year starter until his knee got wrecked. Never the same after that. [NT] - ND521 - 12:11am 4/1/21
- I’d go where I felt most comfortable. - Napoleon - 7:59pm 3/31/21
  - Yep, understood. [NT] - Frankx - 11:18pm 3/31/21
- So right now you must be overweight compared to HS, a little on the short side and slightly slow of - whatsamataU - 7:46pm 3/31/21
  - Really, really weak response. Basically, you just won the Lotto - Frankx - 11:21pm 3/31/21
- No. rees is not an elite O coach. [NT] - Aragoto - 7:16pm 3/31/21
  - I'm hoping u r wrong. Hoping. [NT] - Frankx - 11:23pm 3/31/21
- Right now they seem to be going to Clemson, Ohio State, Georgia, and Alabama. Kelly would need to hi - holybull101 - 6:37pm 3/31/21
- Considering the OLine and the rest of the very talented players at ND - Yes - however, knowing - jimbasil - 4:19pm 3/31/21
  - I was thinking about this earlier today, I think BK's mental illness with QBs started with Golson - holybull101 - 6:30pm 3/31/21
    - Well, Rees wasn't mobile, in fact he was the opposite of that and he had no arm - jimbasil - 9:15pm 3/31/21
    - USC’s current QB was a 6’2 180 pound 3* prospect. [NT] - Napoleon - 8:02pm 3/31/21
      - Book - 3* and 5'10" no arm. [NT] - jimbasil - 9:16pm 3/31/21
        Is he 5’10? - Napoleon - 10:12pm 3/31/21
        No way Book is over 5'11". A pal of mine stood next to him in 2019 at some - jimbasil - 10:18pm 3/31/21
        He was measured at 6’0 for NFL observers at his pro day. - Napoleon - 10:26pm 3/31/21
        instead of comparing one or two, look at the QBs over the past decade. - holybull101 - 10:45pm 3/31/21
        Definitley the best way to compare. Most however, pick their favorite two and call that the sample. [NT] - oldirish - 9:35pm 4/1/21
        
        Jurkovec was 6-5. Kizer was 6-4. - Napoleon - 11:01pm 3/31/21
        you're not even being honest listing walk-ons on their roster - holybull101 - 12:07am 4/1/21
        I’m being honest. I just pulled up their 2020 roster and listed the QBs. - Napoleon - 7:41am 4/1/21
        How many 5'9" QBs have you seen play a down; not named Flutie? [NT] - oldirish - 9:37pm 4/1/21
        
        Maybe this will help: starting with the 2012 class, I compared the heights of USC & ND QB recruits. - Napoleon - 9:30am 4/1/21
        Thank you for disproving someone's theory with real facts. We need more of this. [NT] - oldirish - 9:38pm 4/1/21
        
        fine, i just have guys like Book, Golson, Zaire, and Wimbush in my head [NT] - holybull101 - 12:52pm 4/1/21
        I understand. Sorry if I came off as belligerent. - Napoleon - 2:18pm 4/1/21