Pyne is an average QB, on a good day.

AlbanyIRISH 27134 posts Original UHND Member

Posted 9:08 pm on Oct 18, 2022

He doesn't have the arm strength to make accurate mid and long range passes.

Kind of reminds me of when Rocket Ismail played for Notre Dame
Invincibility with no vulnerability

Replies 52

Pyne is an average QB, on a good day. AlbanyIRISH 9:08pm · 10/18/22
- Pyne was a 4 Star Elite 11 QB BillsND 2:01pm · 10/19/22
  - So was Winbush.NT Frank L 12:45pm · 10/20/22
- And a bad QB on an average dayNT OklahomaIrishman 11:44pm · 10/18/22
- He is more than good enough to win all the games so far with proper coaching and gameplans.NT GaSubwayIrish 11:26pm · 10/18/22
  - How many QBs is he better than, vs. the teams we have played so far ?NT OklahomaIrishman 12:11am · 10/19/22
    - Very Good Question....I hesitate to give the answerNT lmcdonald 1:31pm · 10/19/22
      - See below. Pyne is rated better than 3 of the 5.NT oldirish 2:40pm · 10/19/22
    - Doesn't hold water. Per ESPN QBR, Pyne is 28th out of 121 putting him inside the top 25% of college Link oldirish 1:03pm · 10/19/22
      - Cal's QB, Stanford's QB, Marshall's QB. Only BYU (by 8 spots) and UNC's are better. Oddly enough the oldirish 1:07pm · 10/19/22
    - Game plans suck! QB coaching sucks and has sucked. Pyne is good enough.NT GaSubwayIrish 1:40am · 10/19/22
      - Pyne isn't good enough.NT jimbasil 12:53pm · 10/19/22
        
        With all do respect. He's ranked 28th. That's a lot better than what your eyes are seeing and your oldirish 11:31pm · 10/19/22
        
        Explain how Pyne is 3-0 going into Stanford but not good enough?! GaSubwayIrish 3:18pm · 10/19/22
        
        Pyne is good enough as a game manager ndunabomber 9:17am · 10/20/22
        
        Bout the size of it. No reason that game should have been lost even with Pyne. Frank L 12:44pm · 10/20/22
      - You aren’t wrong. But he also isn’t a difference maker that you need to step up against better Frank L 12:36pm · 10/19/22
        
        I never said he was a difference maker. I concede he isn't. GaSubwayIrish 3:09pm · 10/19/22
      - Biggest flaw... ndunabomber 11:54am · 10/19/22
        
        This is 100% true. One of the few advantages of being there is you can see stuff like that. Frank L 12:30pm · 10/19/22
        
        I agree with this. But this performance doesn't erase what he did the previous 3 games. GaSubwayIrish 3:34pm · 10/19/22
        
        He is good enough to win sometimes if things are set up properly for him and he’s having a good day. Frank L 12:49pm · 10/20/22
        
        You seem to forget that Pyne had a TD pass overturned as well. GaSubwayIrish 12:15pm · 10/19/22
        
        He also had an int erased against Marshall, which you and Old Guy said means it doesn’t count Frank L 12:33pm · 10/19/22
        
        He's 3-1, and the 1 was digging out of someone elses hole. Let's only focus on the 1. Makes senseNT oldirish 11:33pm · 10/19/22
        
        LOL. His Marshall appearance is hardly a measuring stick of how good he is. But you are right .. GaSubwayIrish 3:11pm · 10/19/22
        
        And anyone who puts any blame on the defense just doesn't know football. They gave up 16 pts. GaSubwayIrish 12:11pm · 10/19/22
        
        They don’t give up a lot of points, but they have some glaring flaws. Too many 3rd downs given up, Frank L 1:41pm · 10/19/22
        
        Serious ? When was the last time anything re: ND football was elite? Gotta start where you are.NT oldirish 2:42pm · 10/19/22
        
        Your last sentence is my point. QBs this year were starting their very first games in college. GaSubwayIrish 12:08pm · 10/19/22
        
        BingoNT oldirish 1:09pm · 10/19/22
- Really? Was told here he has "it"...and that the top programs would have recognized he has "it"... TakethetrainKnute 10:34pm · 10/18/22
- Re: Pyne is an average QB, on a good day. Rocketman84 10:18pm · 10/18/22
- Exactly. He was a back up to another mediocre QB for a reason. Still, no reason he couldn’t Frank L 9:29pm · 10/18/22
  - Most QB's would have been mediocre with the awful line play in the first two games. ndunabomber 9:21am · 10/19/22
- agree...esp when he is on the move.NT BaronVonZemo 9:21pm · 10/18/22
- ^^^THIS^^^ Exactly. Spot on.NT tky21 9:19pm · 10/18/22
- If only we were an average football team most days?NT oldirish 9:09pm · 10/18/22

View Full Conversation