Is it possible for us to win out and not get in?

cpirish 347 posts Joined: Oct 11, 2009

Posted 10:26 pm on Oct 9, 2024

Asking because I read somewhere that rankings are not figured into the selection committee's choices.

Replies 42

Is it possible for us to win out and not get in? cpirish 10:26pm · 10/9/24
- No! If the irish win out they will be in the top 6.NT brian irish 10:53am · 10/10/24
- Is it possible for us to win out? Zander 10:39am · 10/10/24
  - Thank youNT WoodstockIrish 8:09am · 10/11/24
  - It's improbable.NT iairishcheeks 11:09am · 10/10/24
  - Good question... TakethetrainKnute 10:41am · 10/10/24
- Very possible D2 10:19am · 10/10/24
  - Agreed. We don't have a schedule that holds water & doesn't provide any form of supporting argumentNT oldirish 9:25pm · 10/10/24
  - Thank you…an actual voice of reasonNT WoodstockIrish 10:25am · 10/10/24
- Not after last weekend.NT BaronVonZemo 8:38am · 10/10/24
- No! Those in front of have too many probable losses.NT Curly1918 7:34am · 10/10/24
- Yes, our SOS may be an issue. It is still too soon to know.NT bobdrake 12:53am · 10/10/24
- IMO, more likely to get in at 10-2 then left out at 11-1. iairishcheeks 12:34am · 10/10/24
  - Above my pay grade... See this team as out at 10-2 and in at 11-1...NT TakethetrainKnute 10:40am · 10/10/24
  - Huh?NT WoodstockIrish 7:47am · 10/10/24
    - Just take a look at the pre-bowl rankings over the last few years.Link iairishcheeks 10:20am · 10/10/24
      - I think you have to discount history to a certain extent D2 10:10am · 10/11/24
        
        Well reasoned argument. iairishcheeks 11:12am · 10/11/24
        
        The other risk is ACC/BIg 12 getting two teams each D2 2:32pm · 10/11/24
        
        This is the perfect storm this year WoodstockIrish 4:37pm · 10/11/24
      - So you think 11-1 is a lock? WoodstockIrish 10:28am · 10/10/24
        
        That's two different questions: Do I think we'll finish 11-1, no. Do I think we're definitely in.. Chrisb 11:30am · 10/10/24
        
        Look at 2022, pre bowls, there were 2 undefeated teams and 2 one loss teams. iairishcheeks 10:03pm · 10/10/24
        
        I'm sure there's some point to this...I just don't know what it is.NT Chrisb 12:08am · 10/11/24
        
        Here, tell me which 12 teams make the playoffs if it was '22 and their records.Link iairishcheeks 12:44am · 10/11/24
        
        I still don't understand what your point is or what '22 has to do with anything.. Chrisb 12:21pm · 10/11/24
        Continue 7 replies
        
        In at 11-1, thinking about being 10-2 hurts my head too much.NT THEISMANCARR 6:52pm · 10/10/24
        
        Jaysus, a lock to be in the playoffs. Try to keep up.NT iairishcheeks 10:34am · 10/10/24
    - Right! I think I might maybe have an idea what he means.. Chrisb 8:11am · 10/10/24
      - Yep. It might help if he knew the difference between then and thanNT Irish_Demon 8:45am · 10/10/24
        
        Must be nice to never have made a typo on your phone.NT iairishcheeks 10:21am · 10/10/24
        
        Yep. All the things.NT Chrisb 9:25am · 10/10/24
- Nah.NT THEISMANCARR 11:48pm · 10/9/24
- For certain, anything is possible.....but... nddad98 11:38pm · 10/9/24
- NoNT Nigel Tufnel 11:23pm · 10/9/24
- Doubtful at this point…NT TakethetrainKnute 10:50pm · 10/9/24

View Full Conversation