Why do people keep saying a 2-loss or 3-loss team gets in over us? There aren't 2 spots. There are not 4 spots. There are 12 teams that make it. Multiple 2-loss SEC and BIG teams can be ranked higher than us, get into the playoffs, and ND still gets in.
There will be attrition at the top as teams play each other.
There will be attrition at the top as they lose games they shouldn't.
If you look at historical BCS and CFP rankings, there are barely any 2-loss P5 teams that don't make Top 12.
NIU was a bad loss. But it was a bad, EARLY loss, and if it ends up being a bad ONLY loss there is approximately 0% chance ND misses CFP.
Replies to: "There will not be 12 other teams that get in before a 1-loss ND, and nobody is ignoring NIU"
- ND’s best chance is for A&M to do damage in the SEC. It’s not inconceivable that a three loss team - irish93 - 7:41am 10/15/24
(27) [View All]
- I just want A&M to do damage to LSU. [NT] - Curly1918 - 2:50pm 10/15/24
- There is zero chance an 11-1 ND team is left out [NT]
- MarkHarman - 12:50pm 10/15/24
- Probably right. But the committee left out a 13-0 FSU last year [NT]
- irish93 - 1:24pm 10/15/24
- Of a FOUR team playoff [NT]
- Turkish - 1:29pm 10/15/24
- True. But it shows the committee does not have to rely on rankings. These are all hypotheticals but - irish93 - 1:36pm 10/15/24
- ND is always going to get a little extra credit—it’s just $s. They are least likely to be left out. [NT] - Shadow_of_the_Dome - 4:59pm 10/15/24
- True. But it shows the committee does not have to rely on rankings. These are all hypotheticals but - irish93 - 1:36pm 10/15/24
- Of a FOUR team playoff [NT]
- Turkish - 1:29pm 10/15/24
- Probably right. But the committee left out a 13-0 FSU last year [NT]
- irish93 - 1:24pm 10/15/24
- Here we go again. . . Let’s hope they finish with only 1 loss before we worry about the playoffs. - irishfaninPA - 12:31pm 10/15/24
- yep [NT] - D2 - 2:11pm 10/15/24
- well, there is this to consider: - und67 - 11:07am 10/15/24
- No, it wouldn’t be for other teams.It was an early trap game, bad,but not lethal alone. But everyone - BaronVonZemo - 9:07am 10/15/24
- This is a terrible recycled argument with no basis in reality. You can "conceive" what you want - Turkish - 8:57am 10/15/24
- ^^This^^ [NT] - Nigel Tufnel - 1:26pm 10/15/24
- Yet there likely will be multiple 2 loss SEC and Big 10 teams that could get in ahead of us - WoodstockIrish - 10:36am 10/15/24
- There will not be 12 other teams that get in before a 1-loss ND, and nobody is ignoring NIU - Turkish - 12:39pm 10/15/24
- The only 3 loss team that gets in before a 1 loss ND is a 3 loss Conf Champ. [NT]
- Chrisb - 8:55am 10/15/24
- Do you agree however that more than one 2-loss SEC or Big 10 teams could get in before us? - WoodstockIrish - 10:40am 10/15/24
- Yeah I do agree about some 2 loss teams, just no 3 loss teams.. - Chrisb - 2:42pm 10/15/24
- So you’re saying it isn’t inconceivable. So glad you chimed in. [NT]
- jimbasil - 9:07am 10/15/24
- It's inconceivable that a 1-loss ND team ranks worse than 12th and misses playoff. [NT]
- Turkish - 9:14am 10/15/24
- But we wouldn't have to rank 12th... - Chrisb - 9:24am 10/15/24
- The megaconferences de-risked this outcome. Top 2 teams from ACC/BIG/SEC/Big12 make Champ Game - Turkish - 9:39am 10/15/24
- But we wouldn't have to rank 12th... - Chrisb - 9:24am 10/15/24
- It isn’t inconceivable that a 5 loss team gets in before an undefeated #1 ranked ND... - Chrisb - 9:12am 10/15/24
- Glad you’re clearing up what 93 posted because he was very clear in his post. - jimbasil - 11:12am 10/15/24
- Actually it wasn't...he didn't say anything about Conf Champs. - Chrisb - 2:40pm 10/15/24
- oh yeah, gonna just piss off because you’re the big bully on the football board. [NT]
- jimbasil - 2:56pm 10/15/24
- No, just because you are a babbling idiot. [NT]
- Chrisb - 6:28pm 10/15/24
- Yeah, tough guy. [NT] - jimbasil - 11:09pm 10/15/24
- No, just because you are a babbling idiot. [NT]
- Chrisb - 6:28pm 10/15/24
- oh yeah, gonna just piss off because you’re the big bully on the football board. [NT]
- jimbasil - 2:56pm 10/15/24
- Actually it wasn't...he didn't say anything about Conf Champs. - Chrisb - 2:40pm 10/15/24
- Glad you’re clearing up what 93 posted because he was very clear in his post. - jimbasil - 11:12am 10/15/24
- It's inconceivable that a 1-loss ND team ranks worse than 12th and misses playoff. [NT]
- Turkish - 9:14am 10/15/24
- Do you agree however that more than one 2-loss SEC or Big 10 teams could get in before us? - WoodstockIrish - 10:40am 10/15/24