This whole conversation is stupid. If they win out they are in. If they don't they are out.

| Register

This whole conversation is stupid. If they win out they are in. If they don't they are out.

Author: murph92675 (1414 Posts - Original UHND Member)

Posted at 6:33 pm on Oct 15, 2024

View All

The committee will take 2 teams from each conference and the 12 seed - thats 9 teams - leaves 3 spots. They are not taking a 3rd place team or a 4th place team over a one loss ND team.

This message has been edited 1 time(s).

Replies to: "This whole conversation is stupid. If they win out they are in. If they don't they are out."

USA Today article today has ND on the outside of the playoff. - SanJoseCAFan - 5:36pm 10/15/24 (32) [View All]
- This is all fun each week predict the 12-team field will be at the end....a lot football left to - NEPA Irish - 2:45pm 10/16/24
- Good chance LSU loses this weekend. [NT] - ThePaleHorseman - 9:28am 10/16/24
  - They have a good chance of losing their next 3 games, but specifically.. - Chrisb - 10:20am 10/16/24
- No, let’s not ‘say this is accurate’ - Nigel Tufnel - 9:02pm 10/15/24
- All this is a projection if the season was over today. It isn't. There are a lot of games left - McIrish - 7:31pm 10/15/24
  - No, this is a projection if the season plays out as they project - admiraltact - 8:35am 10/16/24
    - Well this is not correct [LINK] - McIrish - 10:26am 10/16/24
      - Re: Well this is not correct - admiraltact - 10:36am 10/16/24
        Thank you for making my point - McIrish - 11:23am 10/16/24
  - Agree 100% [NT] - Chrisb - 9:01pm 10/15/24
- This whole conversation is stupid. If they win out they are in. If they don't they are out. - murph92675 - 6:33pm 10/15/24
- I don't see Clemson in over us if they have 2 losses and we have 1. [NT] - Chrisb - 6:31pm 10/15/24
  - Chrisb, agree. But it's the ND as pretender thing. Clemson has power legitimacy. ND doesn't [NT] - SteveM - 8:23pm 10/15/24
    - You gotta look at the schedules...Clemson hasn't beaten one team that is even .500... - Chrisb - 8:35pm 10/15/24
      - Right. Proves my point about power legitimacy apart from schedule. Clemson has it. ND doesn't. [NT] - SteveM - 7:51am 10/16/24
        Re: Right. Proves my point about power legitimacy apart from schedule. Clemson has it. ND doesn't. - Chrisb - 8:16am 10/16/24
        Yes, it's not fair. But it is what it is. ND needs a pattern of high quality (signature) wins. - SteveM - 8:20am 10/16/24
        Yeah, I agree..just didn't catch that as your point. [NT] - Chrisb - 8:27am 10/16/24
        Thanks. To beat a dead horse: 6-0 Indiana is #11 because it's Indiana. - SteveM - 9:37am 10/16/24
        Well said. [NT] - WoodstockIrish - 1:48pm 10/16/24
  - Or a 4th place Tennesee Really? [NT] - murph92675 - 6:39pm 10/15/24
    - Tenn still has to play Bama, Georgia, and Vandy.. - Chrisb - 8:32pm 10/15/24
      - In other words we play no one and will back into the playoff - WoodstockIrish - 9:27pm 10/15/24
        Not our fault Miami backed out of playing us or that FSU blows or that USC is meh.. - Chrisb - 12:06am 10/16/24
        
        See 2023 Michigan [NT] - McIrish - 10:09pm 10/15/24
      - So things will pan out. [NT] - whatsamataU - 8:42pm 10/15/24
        Who knows...we have to win out minus Benjamin Morrison - Chrisb - 8:48pm 10/15/24
        Correct and including years to come! [NT] - whatsamataU - 8:55am 10/16/24
        Not sure what years to come have to do with this.. - Chrisb - 5:49pm 10/16/24
        
        Deservedly so [NT] - WoodstockIrish - 9:27pm 10/15/24
- SEC isn't going to get 5 teams in. - D2 - 6:11pm 10/15/24
- LSU or Tenn or Ala will have 3 losses. [NT] - BaronVonZemo - 5:47pm 10/15/24